A disclaimer from Dr. Hes before we dive in: No milestone is set in stone. “Most babies smile around the time they turn two months old,” she says. “But some babies may have a social smile at six weeks and some may develop it closer to three months.” In other words, if your little one doesn’t flash a smile exactly at the two-month mark, don’t fret. Everything varies, depending on the baby.
How to tell the difference between a smile that’s social versus one that’s more of a reflex (the case with gas)? A social smile is typically in direct response to something. Say, a humor-infused board book reading. Or an over-the-top diaper change. If your newborn smiles in connection to that—external stimuli—it’s genuine. (Even the sight of their mama can spark a grin.) You’ll also know because you’ll see their eyes light up. Even with newborns, there’s an emotional connection that’s very much visible when they flash a real smile.
On the other hand, if a smile is short and random—or occurs while they’re sleeping—it’s more likely to simply be a reflex. “Prior to two months of age, some babies have grimaces or primitive smiles. This may also be passing of gas,” Dr. Hes explains. “There is usually no social intent with these smiles and they cannot be elicited again on demand.” (A social smile can typically be repeated in the moment when you recreate the same stimuli.)