10 ‘Severance’ Season 2 Theories for All You Innies and Outies Out There

Cat’s out of the bag, and everybody now knows that Mark and co. were trying to revolt. The Lumon big-wigs could, of course, simply fire the rebels or rely on the fact that their outies are still in the dark and that’s all that matters. But my money is on supreme retaliation. My first thought is that everybody is getting sent to the break room* or down the creepy elevator shaft for their naughty deeds. But I think it will go a step further. I’ve seen settings on the control panel like “branch transfer” and “clean slate.” Instead of risking the defiant innies going rogue again, might Milchick wipe their memories clean entirely?

*The break room always makes me think of the “calm down corner” in my daughter’s first grade classroom, where disruptive children are sent to look at a picture of palm trees.

Sort of an obvious out, but when Mark screams “she’s alive!” it could appear to Devon that he’s referring to the baby, whom everyone thought was missing. If the writers want a way to keep Mark’s friends and family in the dark, this is an easy one.

Yes, Burt has retired. Yes, Irv has seen his innie crush canoodling with another guy. But, based on the fact that Christopher Walken is back for Season 2, I’m betting these two lovebirds aren’t entirely finished. Will something about seeing Irv at his house spark a memory for Burt? Will Burt’s chip be reimplanted? Did innie Irv leave a message for his outie telling himself to keep Burt in the picture?

Apple TV+ has confirmed both the returning cast and a whole host of new faces: Gwendoline Christie, Merritt Wever, Bob Balaban, Alia Shawkat, Robby Benson, Stefano Carannante, Ólafur Darri Ólafssonand John Noble. I have to imagine some of these newcomers will be brought in as new employees and corporate overlords; how great would Bob Balaban be at passive-aggressively criticizing your data refinement sorting? But I also wonder if we’re gearing up to give Mark a love interest—either in the real world (to distract his outie from thinking too much about Lumon) or at work (to complicate things after his season finale kiss with Helly).

I got many juicy hints in season one about why Harmony is obsessed with severance technology—the fact that she stalked Mark on her own time, the fact that she was clearly happy to learn that outie Mark sensed something was wrong with his innie, the fact that she has a bizarro Lumon shrine including a hospital bracelet that says “Charlotte Cobel 3/17/44.” As I theorized last season, I believe that Lumon’s larger purpose (more on that later) is tied to Harmony Cobel’s personal one: finding out if a totally dead or nearly dead person (perhaps her mother, Charlotte?) can be “reintegrated” and brought to life again.

Unless his memory is wiped, innie Mark will return to Lumon knowing that Ms. Casey is actually Gemma. But Ms. Casey has now been retired and sent down the elevator of doom to who knows what. You’ll recall from Petey’s map that there’s a wing of the building where “some people may live.” Is Ms. Casey (along with the other waffle party sex slaves) living down there, an empty vessel waiting to be re-chipped and sent back into the Lumon halls? Which brings me to…

The goats! The goats! Mark my words we will find out what the deal is. And mark my other words: The deal is cloning. Over the course of season one, I went back and forth on whether or not Lumon was taking braindead bodies and re-animating them with chips. I’m now thinking that, instead, they are cloning dead or nearly dead people, then implanting the clones with the same chips used for severed employees. This explains Harmony’s hopes for cloning Charlotte, whoever she may be, and the goats—because if I know anything about goats, it’s that they’re good for cloning.

I know that when the outies arrive for work, their brain goes through a transformation as they ride to their correct floor. When they're released to the outside world, the same process happens—but what about those who never leave? For instance, there's Ms. Casey, who goes to a lower level and, most likely, goes through a different kind of shift.

According to one Reddit user, it's likely that other employees are stored and left in a comatose state. They wrote, "I think they're experimenting with severance technology on people who are otherwise comatose or even brain dead—the chips allow them to create a new, severed personality that bypasses the damaged parts of the brain. Those people would be, by necessity, permanent innies who could only function in 'innie mode.'"

If you've seen the trailer for season two, then you might recall the clip where Mark abruptly stops running and stares in total shock at three strangers who seem to have taken the places of Helly, Irv and Dylan. What if this is part of the company's plan to trick Mark or mislead him? One Reddit user writes, "I think they are going to severely gaslight Mark and tell him that this is indeed Helly, Irv, and Dylan—they always looked like that, and the actors will play along—OR they could have a copy of the data file copied from their chips."

Another possibility? They'll replace Ms. Casey as well. The Reddit fan continues, "Then they’ll take him to see Ms. Casey (the new Ms. Casey) and say, 'See! This isn’t Gemma! It looks a bit like her, but now you can clearly see that Ms. Casey looks nothing like this picture of Gemma.'"

When innie Helly (disguised as outie Helly) sees her father at the gala, he creepily says, “One day you’ll sit with me at my revolving.” And as we Severance-fans know, there are no throwaway lines on this show. So what’s a revolving, you ask? My theory is that it ties into Lumon’s bigger purpose, which goes way beyond sorting “scary” numbers. I think the Egans are finally realizing their megalomanic dream of living forever—in the form of severing their brains and inserting the chips into cloned bodies after their deaths. Could all of Lumon be in the service of this dystopian vision, enabling the powerful to live forever and the meek to live imprisoned in the basement having their bodies harvested for parts?

Sounds like must-see TV to me!