ComScore

2 Hit Shows Premiered 20 Years Ago This Week—One Still Holds Up, the Other...Not So Much

They add up to 636 episodes of (mostly) entertaining TV

Greys Anatomy The Office 20 year anniversary: Collage
Chris Haston/NBCU Photo Bank; Bob D'Amico/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Want to feel old or guilty that you watch too much TV, or both? Consider this—the same week in 2005, America got two new characters they’d fall in love with (and sometimes love to hate): Meredith Grey on Grey’s Anatomy and Michael Scott on The Office. That was 20 years ago this week, and here’s my humble opinion about how and why Grey’s Anatomy is still going strong, and the reasons The Office sputtered to an end in 2013. (But there’s signs of life via a reboot—more on that in a minute.)

I’m not ashamed to say I still remember watching the first episode of Grey’s when it aired on ABC on March 27, 2005. The neurotic-but-cute Meredith Grey seemed cool, assuaging her night-before jitters as an intern by hooking up with an angelic-looking guy in a bar. I was surprised when, the next day, it turned out her boss was that guy, Derek Shepard aka McDreamy, and an on-again/off-again romance and series trademark of wild occurrences and coincidences was launched.

Just a few days earlier on NBC, March 24, 2005, The Office premiered. Initially I was underwhelmed, since I’d loved the original English version of the series starring Ricky Gervais, which I thought was edgier and funnier. However, Micheal Scott grew on me as the clueless, tone-deaf leader of an unassuming office named Dunder-Mifflin in Scranton, Pennsylvania. Additionally, I grew fond of this pack of unremarkable but lovably relatable office workers too, and I joined the rest of America in my repelled attraction to both the mocumentary form and the cringe comedy genre, both of which would recur in subsequent series like Parks & Recreation.

Greys Anatomy The Office 20 year anniverary: characters Meredith and Derek
Bob D'Amico/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Both series have exceptional elements—Thank you, Grey’s, for bringing the entertainment dynamo Shonda Rhimes to our screens (btw, her new show The Residence is generating buzz) and crossover film star Katherine Heigl to the romcom. And above all, thanks for committing to the bit…I’m talking 21 seasons and 435 episodes of crazy star-crossed love (like when Meredith inspired TikTok’s “choose me” meme by begging Derek to love her in season 2, and then in season 5, when Heigl’s Izzie had sex with the ghost of her deceased heart patient, Denny, who left her $8.7 million). Mass shootings, bombs in chests, principal characters drowning then appearing alive in a subsequent episode—this show went there. And it pulled it off with accuracy no less, and that’s probably why, 20 years later even having lost its main character Meredith Grey, it’s still going strong, keeping us interested with new twists.

Greys Anatomy The Office 20 year anniversary: The Office cast
Chris Haston/NBCU Photo Bank/Getty

The Office, however, got a bit outlandish as it aged. Michael Scott’s well-meaning but…limited ability to be a worker among workers grew a bit tired, even as the ensemble cast stepped up to entertain. Beetroot farmer Dwight Schrute, office crushes Pam and Jim, sassy Kelly Kapoor—the show dependably churned through air time for all, steadily feeding us bits of romance between the principles. But when Steve Carell left the show in 2011, the remaining seasons sputtered without the central black hole of his character Michael’s vacuousness to revolve around. He came back for a cameo on the finale, but it was bittersweet.

Now, however, Peacock is in the works, with rumors swirling that series creator Greg Daniels has assembled a writer’s room and a cast list including known comedy talent as well as stars such as film star Domhnall Gleeson (About Time) and actor/Tony Award winning playwriter Tracy Letts (August Osage County). (Note—Letts is husband to Carrie Coon from The White Lotus season 3 and The Gilded Age, so fingers crossed for a guest spot from her.) And here’s the special sauce—Oscar Nunez is returning as Oscar Martinez, the affable guy in the original gang for all nine seasons. No details about when we might see this reboot, but here’s hoping creator Daniels again makes that paper in a successful desk-bound comedy.



dana dickey

Senior Editor

  • Writes about fashion, wellness, relationships and travel
  • Oversees all LA/California content and is the go-to source for where to eat, stay and unwind on the west coast
  • Studied journalism at the University of Florida

entertainment
/ Abby Hepworth
The Best Comedy I Watched Last Year Deserves *Way* More Attention
entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
As a Girl Mom, I’m Glad the New ‘Snow White’ Exists (Despite All Its Flaws)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
The Top 10 Netflix Shows Right Now (Including a New Uzo Aduba Mystery at #3)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
ABC Announces ‘Golden Bachelor in Paradise’ TV Show (& I Have Mixed Feelings)
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Who Is 'Severance' Star Dichen Lachman's Husband?
entertainment
/ Jael Rucker
This Jennifer Lopez Movie Has a 22% Rating on Rotten Tomatoes—But It's One of My Favorite Films of All Time
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Gerard Butler’s New Action Thriller Is the #1 Movie on Netflix—Here’s Why Everyone’s Watching
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
The 20 Best British Crime Dramas of All Time
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Regé-Jean Page Reveals If He’d Ever Return to Netflix’s ‘Bridgerton’
entertainment
/ Dana Dickey
This 'White Lotus' Hidden Love Affair Is Couple Goals
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Tina Fey & Steve Carell Reunite for Netflix’s ‘The Four Seasons’ (& I Can’t Get Over the Star-Studded Cast List)
entertainment
/ Delia Curtis
Reddit Has a Mind-blowing Yellowjackets Theory That Will Change the Whole Way You Think About *This* Character
entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
10 ‘Severance’ Season 3 Theories, After the Season 2 Finale
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
This Classic Comedy Only Has 15% on Rotten Tomatoes, But It's One of the Funniest Movies I've Ever Seen
entertainment
/ Alexia Dellner
As a Boy Mom, I'm Begging You to Watch the Number 1 Show on Netflix
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
15 Shows and Movies to Watch This Weekend, Recommended by Our Editors
See More