ComScore

One of My Favorite Movies of the Year Just Hit #4 on Netflix—but I Have a Bone to Pick with Its Rotten Tomatoes Score

This movie is so, so good

saturday night movie
Hopper Stone / Sony Pictures

The Netflix top ten movies list can be, well, a mixed bag TBH. Each day, the streaming platform updates its ranking of the most watched options. But, just because something is popular doesn't always mean it's great. (Case in point: The number one movie is currently Back in Action...and as our reviewer put it, "Is this the best spy movie I've ever seen? Well, no.")

But sometimes my fellow viewers get it right. And the number four film on the list is one that definitely belongs there and is definitely worth the watch. I'm of course talking about one of my favorite films of 2024, Saturday Night.

Directed by Jason Reitman (Juno), Saturday Night follows Lorne Michaels and the original cast of Saturday Night Live in the hour-and-a-half leading up to the show's first ever live episode in 1975. The dialogue and some of the events are fictionalized, but the movie is based on a true story. And in case you forget which famous faces were involved with the initial SNL episode, we've got Billy Crystal, Chevy Chase, Gilda Radner, Dan Aykroyd, Jane Curtin, George Carlin, Milton Berle, Al Franken, Andy Kaufman, John Belushi and more.

As I previously wrote when I first saw the film in theaters, the movie "is funny, chaotic and absolutely enthralling. The fast-paced plot is less concerned with character development (though we do get gems involving each of the famous faces) and more focused on the perfect storm that occurred on that October night in 1975, which brought about the revolutionary show that is still airing today."

I continued, "The movie has more than a few laugh out loud scenes (including Nicholas Braun's Kaufman doing his iconic 'Mighty Mouse' number) and the one-liners fly so fast it's hard to catch them all."

Needless to say, I love the film. But I do have a bone to pick with its Rotten Tomatoes score.

According to the critics, yes, the film is "certified fresh," but it only has a 79 percent score. 79?? That's a C+, y'all, and this is an A+ movie. That score should definitely be in the high 90s in my humble opinion.

And while I'm picking bones, I've got another one. This fab film should have been nominated for more awards. Lead actor Gabriel Labelle was nominated for a Golden Globe for his performance (he lost to Sebastian Stan), but the movie is so good it should have been in consideration for Best Picture, both at the Golden Globes and at the Academy Awards. Sadly, it was not.

But not so sadly, I now get to stream it whenever I want on Netflix.

Stay up-to-date on every entertainment story by subscribing to our mailing list here.



Philip Mutz Headshot

VP, News and Entertainment

  • Oversees news and entertainment content
  • Is an award-winning playwright and has hosted two entertainment podcasts
  • Has 10+ years experience in entertainment coverage and viral media

entertainment
/ Abby Hepworth
The Best Comedy I Watched Last Year Deserves *Way* More Attention
entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
As a Girl Mom, I’m Glad the New ‘Snow White’ Exists (Despite All Its Flaws)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
The Top 10 Netflix Shows Right Now (Including a New Uzo Aduba Mystery at #3)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
ABC Announces ‘Golden Bachelor in Paradise’ TV Show (& I Have Mixed Feelings)
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Who Is 'Severance' Star Dichen Lachman's Husband?
entertainment
/ Dana Dickey
2 Hit Shows Premiered 20 Years Ago This Week—One Still Holds Up, the Other...Not So Much
entertainment
/ Jael Rucker
This Jennifer Lopez Movie Has a 22% Rating on Rotten Tomatoes—But It's One of My Favorite Films of All Time
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Gerard Butler’s New Action Thriller Is the #1 Movie on Netflix—Here’s Why Everyone’s Watching
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
The 20 Best British Crime Dramas of All Time
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Regé-Jean Page Reveals If He’d Ever Return to Netflix’s ‘Bridgerton’
entertainment
/ Dana Dickey
This 'White Lotus' Hidden Love Affair Is Couple Goals
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Tina Fey & Steve Carell Reunite for Netflix’s ‘The Four Seasons’ (& I Can’t Get Over the Star-Studded Cast List)
entertainment
/ Delia Curtis
Reddit Has a Mind-blowing Yellowjackets Theory That Will Change the Whole Way You Think About *This* Character
entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
10 ‘Severance’ Season 3 Theories, After the Season 2 Finale
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
This Classic Comedy Only Has 15% on Rotten Tomatoes, But It's One of the Funniest Movies I've Ever Seen
entertainment
/ Alexia Dellner
As a Boy Mom, I'm Begging You to Watch the Number 1 Show on Netflix
See More