ComScore

Are All ‘Bachelor’ Couples Destined for Failure?

With Colton Underwood’s season of The Bachelor fast approaching, I can’t stop thinking about whether his journey to find love will end in an engagement or (more likely) an engagement followed by a breakup.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for the 26-year-old virgin finding “the one,” but I’ve invested in far too many Bachelor Nation relationships to delude myself into thinking that the odds are in his favor. While some were expected breakups—like Jake Pavelka and Vienna Girardi or Juan Pablo Galavis and Nikki Ferrell—others shook me to the core (dramatic, I know)—like Ben Higgins and Lauren Bushnell or Kaitlyn Bristowe and Shawn Booth. (Too soon?)

So, is Underwood destined for failure? If not, then what are his chances of being the exception to the rule? Here’s what he’s up against.

arie bachelor crying
Paul Hebert/ABC

The Breakups

Thirty-five couples came out of The Bachelor and The Bachelorette, and only seven are still together. (Womp, womp.)

Of those 28 failed relationships, 12 didn’t make it past the three-month mark. Of course, this includes Arie Luyendyk Jr. and Becca Kufrin’s relationship, which ended before the After the Final Rose special (that has to be a world record).

To be fair, there are several failed couples who really, really tried to make it work. We have season six Bachelor Byron Velvick and Mary Delgado, who broke off their engagement after five years, along with season seven star Charlie O’Connell and Sarah Brice, who dated for four (inconsecutive) years.

But nothing is more heartbreaking (I told you I was invested!) than Bristowe and Booth, who recently ended their engagement after three years together.

becca garrett proposal bachelorette
ABC/Paul Hebert

The Success Stories

Chris Harrison lives for these Bachelor Nation success stories. While most are married with children, there are three couples who haven’t moved past the engagement yet. (Luyendyk Jr. and Lauren Burnham, Rachel Lindsay and Bryan Abasolo, and Jojo Fletcher and Jordan Rodgers have yet to tie the knot, but hey, no rush.)

Of these still-in-love couples, only four have surpassed the five-year mark: Desiree Hartsock and Chris Siegfried, Sean Lowe and Catherine Giudici, Ashley Hebert and J.P. Rosenbaum and—drumroll, please—Trista Rehn and Ryan Sutter, who are going on 15-plus years. *Drops rose*

colton underwood reunion special
ABC/Paul Hebert

The Bottom Line

While I secretly love watching breakups on national television, one thing’s for sure: The Bachelor does work…sometimes.

Sure, more than half of the couples are no longer together. But the ones who have stuck it out have discovered that a TV show is a perfectly normal way to find your soul mate (so there’s hope?).

Come on, Colton. If Trista and Ryan can do it, so can you.



greta

Senior Editor, News and Entertainment

  • Writes and edits news and entertainment content
  • Specializes in breaking celebrity news, royal family coverage and TV show and movie recommendations
  • Has 9 years experience in entertainment coverage

news
/ Danielle Long
Jennifer Garner Shares Rare Throwback with Her Sisters—And Fans Can’t Get Over One Thing
news
/ Danielle Long
Martha Stewart Posts Sultry New Photo and Fans Think She's Aging Backwards
news
/ Danielle Long
Buckingham Palace Posts Striking Portrait of King Charles and Queen Camilla with the Pope (and I Need to Know What's in that Box)
news
/ Danielle Long
Prince George Joins Prince William for Surprise Appearance—and He Looks Like His Dad's Mini-Me
news
/ Danielle Long
Queen Camilla Stuns in Gorgeous Turquoise Dress—and Her Accessories Hold a Very Special Meaning
news
/ Danielle Long
Royal Family Unveils Striking Photo of Queen Camilla and King Charles Standing Alone—and It's Very Out of Character for Both of Them
news
/ Danielle Long
I Just Realized Why 'The White Lotus' Star Walton Goggins Looks Familiar—and I Don't Know How I Missed It
news
/ Danielle Long
Buckingham Palace Just Posted an Emotional Video of King Charles and Queen Camilla Standing Side by Side
news
/ Danielle Long
Meghan Markle Shares Rare Photo of Herself As a Girl Scout And I Can't Get Over This One Detail
news
/ Danielle Long
Netflix’s #1 Movie Has a 94% on Rotten Tomatoes—and It’ll Have You Laughing Till It Hurts
news
/ Danielle Long
Selena Gomez Is Channeling Meghan Markle With This Major Spring Beauty Trend
news
/ Danielle Long
Chrissy Teigen Just Shared a New Pic of Her Youngest—And This Baby’s Got *Major* Cool Kid Energy
news
/ Danielle Long
Meghan Markle Opens Up About Alarming Health Condition on New Podcast: 'I Was Scared'
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
I Noticed an Interesting Detail About King Charles & Queen Camilla's Body Language in Italy
news
/ Danielle Long
Meghan Markle Sends a Message After As Ever Orders Are Cancelled—And It Includes a Sweet Surprise
news
/ Danielle Long
Michelle Williams’s Airline Nightmare Incident Has Everyone Agreeing on This One Thing
See More