Being an awesome gift-giver is great. Being an awesome gift-giver without spending an arm and a leg is better. Way better. If you’re taking part in a Secret Santa gift exchange this year that has a budget of $50 or less, I know it can be a bit tricky to find something that won’t be tossed in the junk drawer. That’s why I scoured the web to find budget-friendly items suitable for every person you could have drawn. Think: a Crock-Pot lunch box for your coworker, a J. Crew scarf for your friend’s friend, a marble cigar ashtray for your uncle (twice removed) and endless snags for your sister or bestie—from a dainty zodiac necklace to a celebrity beloved Barefoot dreams blanket to beauty kits from Olaplex, Rare Beauty, Pat McGrath Labs and beyond.
Here, find the 58 best Secret Santa gifts under $50 that anyone would be happy to open this holiday season.