ComScore

These 21 Customer-Favorite Items from Wayfair Have More Than 1,000 5-Star Reviews—and They're All on Sale for Presidents' Day

5 stars and major savings

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Like our wardrobes, our homes can use a bit of an update every season. Which is why I live for the shopping bonanza that is the Wayfair's Presidents' Day sale. It's one of the retailer's *biggest* events of the year, during which the prices for so many stylish home essentials, from area rugs to comfy accent chairs, are slashed by up to 70 percent—just in time for spring cleaning and summer renovations, no less. And, lucky for me (and you!) the deals featuring some of the lowest prices of the year are officially live from now through Feb 18.

While there are a ton of items across categories included in the sale, I suggest heading straight for some of these customer-favorite best sellers. Considering they've racked up at least a thousand 5-star reviews from happy customers, these beloved buys are practically guaranteed to offer the best bang for your buck, and totally revive your living space in the best way. As for me? I've got my eye on this beloved NutriBullet personal blender and this plush comforter set, but there's plenty more where those came from ahead.

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

Offering a timeless silhouette and plush cushioning, this versatile sleeper sofa is perfect for overnight guests—or upgrading your own nap time. It boasts nearly 3,000 5-star reviews, and it's easy to see why buyers love it so much. It comes with the brand's premium Dream Coil technology, which shoppers claim gives it a sinkable feel while still being firm enough to provide adequate support. The process of switching back and forth between making it a queen-sized sleeper and standard sofa is also super easy, as you just need to lower the backrest and pull out the base. Just take it from on Wayfair shopper, who writes, "I'm impressed by the quality of this sofa for the price. It's firm for sitting, but very comfortable when you slide out the base and use it as a double recliner. I like a firm mattress, so I found it very comfortable to sleep on." Maximum comfort aside, the tufted upholstery is stunning, making this a piece that will transform your entire living room.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: sturdy-but-comfortable cushioning, easy to use, nice design
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 2,807

Best Outdoor Set

2. Three Posts Marciano Adirondack Set 

Three Posts

Made with sturdy poly materials that are also eco-friendly, these modern Adirondack chairs are sleek, easy to assemble and perfect for relaxing outside during the warmer months. Per the brand, they're designed to resist UV rays and fading, and are quick-drying for days when the rain hits. Or as one buyer notes, "Absolutely the best Adirondack chairs you can buy. I got them on sale and bought six for my fire pit. They have been outside in the weather for almost two years and just wiping them clean makes them good as new. Highly recommend for their looks and durability!" Best of all, the design is foldable, making them a breeze to move, store and even carry with you on camping trips.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: weather-resistant, has a foldable design
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 5,690

In need of new pillows that will help you get the good night's sleep you've been craving for months? This set of two will get the job done with their plushy crafting and ultra-comfortable alternative gel-fiber material that regulates your body temperature as you rest. The pillows are also non-toxic, hypoallergenic and OEKO-TEX certified, meaning they're free from harmful chemicals, and are designed to work for all types of sleepers. So whether you're a side, back or stomach sleeper, rest assured you'll be waking up more well-rested in no time.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: free of irritants and harmful chemicals, comfortable, works for all types of sleepers
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 2,084

This classic, mid-century accent chair is totally worth the modest investment as the solid wood frame and durable polyester upholstery works for any space, and can last for years. The minimalist design matches all sorts of decor schemes, and the foam-filled cushioning is hailed for its comfort, with an adequate amount of support to prevent sagging, according to buyers. "Very sturdy, durable and comfortable," writes one shopper, who adds, "It's so easy to put together, and has a great value for the price." While the light gray fabric is my fave, there are six other shades to choose from, allowing you to pick the one that works best for your space and preferences.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: comfortable, easy to assemble, affordable
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 7,299

Best Accent Mirror

5. Wade Logan Azeen Flat Mirror

Azeen

Sleek and chic with the power to enhance any room, this full-length accent mirror can be leaned vertically against a wall or mounted both vertically and horizontally. It comes with an engineered wood frame that has three different finishes to pick from, as well as heights reaching up to 6.5 feet. To that end, it has over 2,000 5-star reviews, one of which raves, "This mirror arrived in perfect condition and packed amazingly well! The black frame is all the same color with no imperfections. It looks great." If you're looking to take more mirror selfies this year, you need this.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: can be wall-mounted, has a nice design
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 2,442

Best Room-Darkening Curtains

6. AllModern Darkening Curtains

AllModern

Not only can these plush velvet curtains help keep the sunshine (and noise) out on bright, sunny mornings when you want to sleep in, but they can also help lock in heat during the colder months. That said, they're great zhuzhing up your decor scheme with their luxurious look according to a ton of reviewers, including this one who writes, "Beautiful coloring and excellent quality. The darkening is a godsend, and they really helped to create a true Victorian flare to my basic bedroom." BTW, they're available in *so many* colors, so you're bound to find a set that matches your interiors.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: great range of colors, nearly blackout, add rich texture and flare to a space
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 4,208

Best Rug Pad

7. Wayfair Basics Bottorff Non-Slip Rug Pad

Wayfair Basics

Looking for a perfectly practical buy that'll instantly upgrade your space? Don't underestimate the power of a good rug pad. Not only will this top-rated option keep your area rugs from slipping around, it'll also make them feel even comfier beneath your feet. "[It's] easy to unfold and flatten [and] provides a nice cushion and stability without adding too much bulk to [the] rug. Good quality, great price," one reviewer raves. Considering the fact that it's also sound-absorbent, you can rest assured it'll keep your floors protected, your soles comfortable and your steps nice and quiet.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: keeps rugs in place, is soundproof, eliminates scratches
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 133,968

Best Sheet Set

8. Wayfair Basics Sheet Set

Wayfair

These wrinkle-resistant sheets are available in multiple colors and come with a fitted sheet, flat sheet and up to four pillowcases for a total bedding transformation. The pockets are 14 inches deep to fit thicker mattresses, and they’re made with ultra-soft microfiber that “feels smooth like silk and very luxurious to sleep on,” according to one member of their fan club. And did I mention they're hypoallergenic? Sweet dreams await!

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: affordable, soft, deep pockets, fits most mattresses
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 68,845

Best Bed Frame with Headboard

9. Willa Arlow Candler Upholstered Wingback Bed

Willa Arlo

Don't be fooled by its budget-friendly sale price—this statement-making upholstered bed frame is praised for going above and beyond in people's homes. "I absolutely love this frame! It fits our small space perfectly and wasn't hard to put together," writes one thrilled buyer. It comes complete with a wingback headboard and it’s available in seven colors to boot.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: gorgeous wingback headboard, available in multiple colors, easy to assemble
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 3,394

Best Mixer

10. Cuisinart Stand Mixer

Cuisinart

Whether you’re gearing up to make tons of goodies or are looking for the perfect gift for an avid baker in your life, this on-sale electric mixer is a winner. It can make dough for up to 13 dozen cookies at a time, and it comes with a dough hook, flat beater and whisk to get everything done with ease. “I love this mixer," a reviewer raves. "It has weight so it doesn’t move around on the countertop when [it’s] in use. [It also] has a powerful motor and does a great job [mixing].”

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: powerful motor, large capacity (prep several dozen cookies at once)
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 4,408

Best Mattress

11. Wayfair Sleep Medium Memory Foam Mattress

Wayfair Sleep

Give yourself a dreamy spot to rest at the end of a long day. This mattress is a top seller thanks to its memory foam filling, featuring a middle layer that is designed to eliminate pressure points along your body, with the mattress also offering cooling properties and a green tea treatment that keeps odors at bay. "Great mattress. Takes about a week or so for it to fully expand, but is very comfortable and very supportive. Feels like sleeping on a cloud. Very large and spacious. Overall I'm very pleased," says one happy customer.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: has cooling properties (!), washable cover, comfortable
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 49,098

Best Platform Bed

12. Red Barrel Studio Harlow Wood Platform Bed

Red Barrel Studio

Add instant storage space to your bedroom with this solid wood platform bed, which raises your mattress off the floor with an underbed clearance of 8.5 inches, offering plenty of room to slide some extra drawers or containers beneath it. The frame, which reviewers describe as "durable and sturdy," comes in varying sizes, and is available in six different stains. "I bought two of these for a small bedroom," notes one buyer. "It's nice, sturdy and easy to put together. The wooden finish is also very pretty!"

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: sturdy, comes in six different stains, easy to install
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 11,371

Best Knife Set

13. Henckels Modernist Knife Block Set

Henckels

This set comes with 12 stainless-steel knives, kitchen shears and a gorgeous knife block to store them all in. Each slot has a built-in sharpener to ensure your knives are ready to slice and dice when you pull them out. One reviewer sums up their performance nicely: "The knives are sharp and have the perfect weight and balance. The product is exactly what I was expecting. Each knife has its own knife sharpener and the knives cut with ease." Even better, they're designed to be rust-resistant, so you can consider this a kitchen investment that'll stand the test of time (and vegetable chopping).

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: well-balanced knives, comes with sharpener
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 6,076

Best Blender

14. NutriBullet Personal Blender

Nutribullet

Whether you’re blending up a smoothie to take on the go or pureeing ingredients for a homemade soup, this NutriBullet will be your small-but-mighty sidekick. It comes with two canisters, a topper and a shaker bottle lid, so you can just blend your ingredients, pop on the cap and go, without having to pour it all into a separate cup. "I have a protein shake every morning, as does my husband, and this has been a game changer," one reviewer says. "It blends all ingredients quickly and completely!"

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: powerful blender in a compact size, includes an on-the-go cup
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 7,273

This set of two accent pillows will supply fluffy comfort and a touch of vintage flair to a sofa or bedding setup. They're wrapped in super soft velvet with a polyester fill and have a nice thickness to them, plus buyers say they maintain their shape wonderfully. "Gorgeous pillows. Texture, color and detail are so reminiscent of my childhood...The color was exactly true, too," one buyer shares.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: reversible, comfy, versatile
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 4,081

Rock and feed the baby or just lounge on your own in this cozy glider recliner that makes for the ultimate nursery chair. It reclines back with a footrest or swivels in place for a peaceful, soothing experience as you get the little one to sleep. "I love this chair—it’s very comfortable and the versatility of rocking, reclining and swiveling is perfection!” one reviewer raves. Psst: You can nab it in this white linen fabric, or choose from a number of different colored velvet options if you're feeling fancy.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: comfortable, swivels, rocks *and* reclines
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 8,564

Best Cooling Mattress

17. Sealy Cool Memory Foam Mattress

Sealy

Upgrade your mattress to this cooling, comfy memory foam number and you'll never go back. It has a medium-soft firmness, which is great for those who don’t love a super hard mattress but still need some support. And don't just take my word for it: "This mattress is so comfortable," gushes customer Leslie V. "I have been struggling with lower back pain, and this mattress allows me to sleep like a baby. It has excellent support—not too firm or soft.” It also offers low-motion transfer, reducing the risk of waking up your partner when you go to get a glass of water. Truly a win on every front.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: medium-soft firmness, cooling, low motion transfer
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 5,952

Best Coffee Maker

18. Cuisinart Grind and Brew Coffee Maker

Cuisinart

Program this gadget to have your cup of freshly ground joe brewed and ready for sippin’ as soon as you wake up in the morning. And if you sleep in late, the warm plate will keep it hot until you’re ready for it. Fair warning: It may make you ditch your French press. "Love this coffee maker," one reviewer says. "We haven't had anything else since we found [it]." To reiterate: This bad boy literally grounds whole coffee beans before turning it into that sweet, caffeinated nectar of the gods. I'd raise a mug to that!

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: timer allows you to wake up to fresh coffee, grinder included
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 1,326

Best Comforter Set

19. Homechoice International Comforter Set

Homechoice

Complete with an elegant quilted comforter and up to two pillow shams, this quality bedding set is made of a microfiber material that shoppers say is *so* soft to the touch. The comforter, meanwhile, has a double stitching overclock with piping that is used to strengthen seams and prevent the fills from escaping, a feature that is appreciated by many buyers. "It’s just the right amount of thickness you want. So you don’t wake up kicking it off in the middle of the night," says one reviewer. Yep, you'll find me (along with thousands of other customers) cuddling up under this beauty all season long.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: ultra soft, quilted style, comes with pillow shams
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 6,188

This is your sign to refresh your bedding with this ultra-luxe single-ply sheet set crafted of 1000-thread count Egyptian cotton that buyers say feels buttery soft on the skin. It’s fixed with a deep pocket fit that can accommodate mattresses up to 16 inches thick, and comes with a pair of matching pillowcases, fitted sheet and flat sheet. One customer says, “These sheets are very nice, great quality, extremely warm and nice fitting. I love the colors and am looking forward to getting more use this winter for sure!”

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: complete set, buttery soft, 100 percent cotton
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 8,744

This six-drawer dresser is the ideal piece of functional furniture to complete your bedroom. Not only is it aesthetically pleasing, with its clean-lined silhouette and neutral, solid finish that’ll go with just about any motif or color palette you please, but it’s also great for optimizing storage and organization for your robust wardrobe. It’s made from engineered wood on metal ball-bearing glides that’s designed to open smoothly (i.e., no sticking). Plus, you can add decor to the top of the dresser to “dress” it up and make it feel more homey, like family photos, coffee table books or a lampshade.

Fast Facts

  • Why Customers Love It: drawers retract smoothly, easy assembly, wide drawers offer ample storage, quality glossy finish
  • Number of 5-Star Reviews: 7,064

olivia dubyak headshot

Commerce Editor

  • Covers commerce content, including personal and collaborative reviews and product roundups across beauty, home, fashion and family verticals
  • More than 5 years of professional experience in journalism
  • Studied journalism at Duquesne University

Destinee Scott Editor Bio Pic

Associate Sales and Deals Editor

  • Stays on top of the best sales and deals across the internet
  • Over 3 years of experience in commerce (covering tentpole sales, like Amazon Prime Day, Black Friday and Way Day)
  • Studied Journalism at St. John's University

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.
home
/ Sydney Meister
Boomers Invested in “Forever Homes.” But Gen Z Is Buying Into “For Now”—Here’s Why
home
/ Sydney Meister
My Honest Review of the Dyson V15 Detect, the Viral Light-Up Vacuum (That's Almost $140 Off RN)
home
/ Destinee Scott
Walmart Super Savings Week Is Saving My Wallet—and These 7 Fashion and Home Scores Will Save Yours, Too
home
/ Sydney Meister
Using This One Word Could Boost Your Home's Value by $11,000
home
/ Alexia Dellner
This Decor Could Boost Your Home’s Value by $12,500 (No, It’s Not Modern Farmhouse)
home
/ Sydney Meister
These 44 Viral Products Are on Major Deal at the Amazon Big Spring Sale (#Need)
home
/ Candace Davison
4 Years Later, These $30 Mellanni Sheets Are Some of the Best I've Ever Owned
home
/ Marissa Wu
5 Tricks to Take More Flattering Photos of Your House, According to an Interior Design Photographer
home
/ Candace Davison
Linen Sheets Seemed Overrated, Until I Tested This Quince Set
home
/ Destinee Scott
At Last! The Amazon Big Spring Sale Is Here, and These 58 Best Deals Are Worth *Running* To
home
/ Destinee Scott
Embrace the Rococo Romance Aesthetic with the New Pottery Barn x LoveShackFancy Home Collection
home
/ Sydney Meister
How to Organize a Fridge: The 6-Step Formula That Never Fails
home
/ Jael Rucker
Clean Freaks, It's Your Lucky Day: The Dyson V11 Vacuum Is $140 Off
home
/ Natalie LaBarbera
Bring on the Bunny Vibes with Mud Pie's Adorable Easter Decor
home
/ Arricca Elin SanSone
Nostalgia Gardens Are the Mood-Booster We All Need—Here's How to Create One
home
/ Arricca Elin SanSone
13 Best Places to Shop for Seeds and Garden Plants, Vetted by a Gardening Expert
See More