ComScore

5 Drinks a Bartender Would Never Order at a Bar

Stay away from those slushie machines, people

Before you order your go-to drink at the no-fuss bar you wandered into, you might want to reconsider. NYC comedian and bartender Tim Dunn spilled all his secrets on the five drinks you should never order at a bar (plus the ones you actually should). Bottoms up!

bartender drinks mojito
Twenty20

Mojito

At your typical bar, you probably won’t get the top-notch ingredients a cocktail like this deserves. Who wants a mojito made with out-of-season mint or crummy limes?

What to order instead: A Bacardi and Diet Coke so you can get your rum fix (and make things way easier on your bartender).

bartender drinks beer
Twenty20

Draft Beer

Draft beer travels from keg to tap through a beer line. And if those beer lines aren’t cleaned frequently, you get bacteria growth (ew). If you want to take a guess at how well a bar cleans its beer lines, check out the bathrooms. 

What to order instead: A bottled beer (no judgment if it’s Coors Light).

Milk-based Cocktails

Bartenders loathe milk-based drinks for a few reasons. Top of the list is that most bars rarely use milk, so their supply is short, nonexistent or—worse—expired. Save that White Russian for a cozy night in. 

What to order instead: A Tito’s and root beer for that vodka kick with a side of sweetness.

bartender drinks wine
Twenty20

Wine

Unless you’re at a wine bar, most bars have super-cheap “house reds.” And as anyone who’s ever lived on a budget has learned, super-cheap wine leads to a brutal hangover.

What to order instead: Jim Beam, straight. It’s no substitute for a glass of wine, but it checks the “complex spirit that can be sipped slowly” box.

square
Twenty20

Anything Frozen

Especially if it’s in a machine. Here’s why: Those machines are rarely cleaned (yuck), and because bartenders keep adding mix and spirits to what’s already being churned, the ratios get thrown off. By the time you’re ordering that blue raspberry margarita, who knows what is actually being swirled around in there. 

What to order instead: An el Jimador and grapefruit juice (or Coke, if we’re talking a bare-bones bar). One sip and you get all the beach vibes minus the complicated machinery plus one happy bartender.



DaraKatz

Executive Editor

  • Lifestyle editor and writer with a knack for long-form pieces
  • Has more than a decade of experience in digital media and lifestyle content on the page, podcast and on-camera
  • Studied English at University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

food
/ Katherine Gillen
42 Easy Spinach Recipes to Make for Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner
food
/ Taryn Pire
The Cheesecake Factory’s Happy Hour Drink Menu, Ranked by a Food Editor
food
/ Katherine Gillen
30 Mother’s Day Cocktails to Show Mom You Love Her (from Bloody Marys to Margs)
food
/ Delia Curtis
Auntie Anne’s, Cinnabon & Oreo United for the Ultimate Sweet Treat Collab and I Taste-Tested It Just for You
food
/ Taryn Pire
87 BBQ Side Dishes That Are Better Than the Main Event
food
/ Taryn Pire
This Retired Taco Bell Menu Item Is Back by Popular Demand (and It May Be for Good)
food
/ Taryn Pire
This Popular Fast Food Chain Is Offering $1 Double Smash Burgers—Here’s How to Get One
food
/ Taryn Pire
New York’s Carnegie Deli Just Launched Mother’s Day Gift Boxes—on Amazon
food
/ Candace Davison
This Under-the-Radar Chain Just Launched a Mac & Cheese Menu—& It's Not to Be Missed
food
/ Taryn Pire
Today in Random but Useful, I Bring You This Tool for Serious Snackers (and It’s on Sale)
food
/ Taryn Pire
Every Panera Bread Salad, Ranked and Reviewed by a Food Editor Who Tasted Them All
food
/ Emma Singer
14 Substitutes for Eggs That Totally Work (Because They’re Expensive Right Now)
food
/ Candace Davison
What to Order at Magnolia Bakery: Cupcakes, Banana Pudding & Desserts, Reviewed
food
/ Taryn Pire
25 Radish Recipes to Make While They’re in Season
food
/ Taryn Pire
36 BBQ Menu Ideas: Recipes That Will Transform Your Backyard Party
food
/ Candace Davison
Starbucks Has a 'Not-So-Secret' Menu & I Can't Stop Ordering Its Latest Creation
See More