ComScore

24 Allergy-Friendly Cookies That Will Please a Crowd

24 Allergy-Friendly Cookies That Will Please a Crowd
Half Baked Harvest

School is starting, the holidays are fast approaching and it’s time to start thinking about big-batch desserts that can win over bake sale customers, PTA members and family and friends at festive celebrations…without triggering any allergic reactions. Indeed, food allergies are a major thing—per the CDC, 6.2 percent of adults and 5.8 percent of children in the United States have one—and they can be life-threatening, too, so it’s best to steer clear when you’re serving up dessert for a crowd.  

As for what foods can trigger such an unfortunate turn of events, Monica T. Kraft, M.D.—a professor and medical practitioner in the allergy and immunology division at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center—tells us that the top eight most common food allergens are “cow’s milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, fish and shellfish…[and that] sesame is also being increasingly identified as the ninth most common food-triggering allergy.” With that in mind, we’ve compiled a list of the tastiest allergy-friendly cookies, so you can bake up something sweet, delicious and safe. Just remember that cross-contamination is always a concern when dealing with food allergies and that any of the following recipes that contain chocolate are only allergy-friendly if you carefully review the label to ensure they are dairy and soy-free. (Psst: These baking chips fit the bill.)

Espresso Chocolate Chip Cookies
MARK WEINBERG/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

1. Espresso Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 1 hour 
    Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, <500 calories, nut-free
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

We’re nuts about these coffee-spiked cookies. Just kidding—there are no nuts involved, but they do make a pretty sweet substitute for your morning Joe.

No Bake Gluten Free Breakfast Cookie for One Allergy Friendly Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL
  • Time Commitment: 35 minutes 
    Why I Love It: high protein, no bake, gluten-free 
  • Allergen Info: no wheat, no peanuts, no eggs 

This delicious no-bake cookie might be the size of your face, but it’s packed with protein and super healthy, so you can eat chocolate for breakfast without even a twinge of guilt. Bonus: It will fuel you till lunchtime and beyond.

Gluten-Free Flourless Cocoa Cookies
THE FEARLESS BAKER

3. Gluten-Free Flourless Cocoa Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 42 minutes 
    Why I Love It: Crowd-pleaser, <500 calories, gluten-free 
  • Allergen Info: no wheat, no peanuts, no tree nuts, no dairy 

If you ever want to indulge in the molten chocolate goodness of a flourless chocolate cake on the go (i.e., without a plate and utensils), this gluten-free treat has got you covered.

SunButter Cookies Allergy Friendly Cookies
PATRICK SPORLEDER/STYLING: KERRI AXELROD

4. SunButter Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes 
    Why I Love It: Crowd-pleaser, <10 ingredients, nut-free 
  • Allergen Info: no wheat, no dairy, no peanuts, no tree nuts 

These protein-packed sunbutter cookies are sweetened with a generous amount of maple syrup, which means they’re so tasty you won’t even notice that they’re actually healthy, too.

Butterscotch Icebox Cookies Allergy Friendly Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

5. Butterscotch Icebox Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 3 hours 10 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, kid-friendly, nut-free 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

Here, a lunchbox gem that will satisfy your kid’s sweet tooth (butterscotch icing!) without breaking the school’s nut-free policy. 

Flourless Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies Allergy Friendly Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

6. Flourless Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 40 minutes 
    Why I Love It: gluten-free, kid-friendly, <500 calories 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts, no wheat 

Forget the gluten and the raisins—we promise you won’t miss either once you bite into one of these soft, chewy and chocolate-packed oatmeal cookies. 

Sweet Potato Sugar Cookies with Marshmallow Topping
CHRISTINE HAN/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

7. Sweet Potato Sugar Cookies with Marshmallow Topping

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes 
    Why I Love It: Special-occasion worthy, beginner friendly, <10 ingredients 
  • Allergen Info: no egg, no peanuts, no tree nuts 

Let’s be honest, the traditional holiday casserole is far too sweet to pass as a dinner side. Turn it into a frosted cookie, however, and you have a recipe for dessert success. 

Spiced Palmiers Allergy Friendly Cookies
CHRISTINE HAN/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

8. Spiced Palmiers

  • Time Commitment: 4 hours 30 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, special occasion-worthy, low carbs 
  • Allergen Info: no egg, no peanuts, no tree nuts 

Here, the classic French puff pastry cookie gets a wintry makeover with a warm spice blend, featuring cinnamon, cardamom, clove and nutmeg. Grab a cup of tea and go to town. 

Cut-Out Sugar Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

9. Cut-Out Sugar Cookies

Time Commitment: 1 hour 30 minutes 
Why We Love It: <10 ingredients, <500 calories, kid-friendly 

•Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

If nut allergies are a concern, you’re always safe with sugar cookies…but maybe not always satisfied. Fortunately, our recipe yields a cookie so buttery and delicious you can skip the decorations all together and still enjoy a palate-pleasing indulgence.

Easy Fortune Cookies
ERIN MCDOWELL

10. Easy Fortune Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes
  • Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, nut-free, beginner-friendly, special occasion-worthy 
  • Allergen Info: no egg, no peanuts, no tree nuts 

Ridiculously easy to make with little more than store-bought dumpling wrappers and a stick of butter—these sugar-crusted fortune cookies are the perfect treat to serve up at a party. Plus, the baking process leaves plenty of room for creativity (in the fortune department, of course) so these guys are as fun to make as they are to eat. 

Coconut Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL

11. Coconut Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes
  • Why I Love It: Crowd-pleaser, one bowl, beginner friendly
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

This perfect, nut-free union of sugar cookie and macaroon, featuring an oh-so pretty coconut flake garnish, belongs in your regular rotation. Trust. 

No Bake Sugar Cookie Truffles Allergy Friendly Cookies
LIZ ANDREW/STYLING: ERIN MCDOWELL
  • Time Commitment: 1 hour 30 minutes
  • Why I Love It: special occasion-worthy, <10 ingredients, no bake 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

Bit off more than you could chew (so to speak) in the sugar cookie department? No problem. Here, leftover sugar cookies, cream cheese and white chocolate come together to make a melt-in-your-mouth truffle that most certainly won’t stick around. 

Berries and Cream Cookies Allergy Friendly Cookies
PHOTO/STYLING: KATHERINE GILLEN

13. Berries and Cream Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 40 minutes
  • Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, <500 calories, kid-friendly 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

That pink icing owes its pretty hue and fruity flavor to a mix of freeze-dried berries, and the end result tastes as good as it looks. 

S’mores Cookies
PHOTO/STYLING: KATHERINE GILLEN

14. S’mores Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 45 minutes
  • Why I Love It: <500 calories, kid-friendly, nut-free 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts 

These cookies have a chewy texture, but all the graham cracker flavor you expect from  a vessel for the more appealing components of the namesake campfire treat. Oh, and there’s no open flame required, so you can just enjoy in the comfort of your own home.

Vegan Black and White Cookies
The Full Helping

15. Vegan Black and White Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 35 minutes
  • Why I Love It: vegan, kid-friendly, special-occasion worthy 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts, no dairy, no egg 

Coterie member Gena Hamshaw gives NYC’s iconic cookie a vegan makeover with help from some non dairy substitutes—and the plant-based finished product is every bit as cakey and sugary sweet as the original. 

Best Ever Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies
Averie Cooks

16. Best Ever Flourless Peanut Butter Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 3 hours 13 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, kid-friendly, gluten-free, one bowl 
  • Allergen Info: no tree nuts, no dairy, no wheat 

Here, a one bowl wonder that doesn’t require a mixer and promises an exceedingly soft and chewy cookie that’s packed with peanut butter flavor and completely gluten-free. 

Crinkle-Top Ginger Molasses Cookies
Bojon Gourmet

17. Crinkle-Top Ginger Molasses Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 1 hour 20 minutes
  • Why I Love It: gluten-free, <500 calories, low carb 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts, no wheat 

Not to be confused with its crispier cousin, the ginger snap—these ginger molasses cookies have a similarly spiced flavor profile, but a soft and chewy texture you can really sink your teeth into. 

Strawberry and Chocolate Ganache Sandwich Cookies Allergy Friendly Cookies
Lexi’s Clean Kitchen

18. Strawberry and Chocolate Ganache Sandwich Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 47 minutes
  • Why I Love It: vegan, gluten-free, kid-friendly 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts, no wheat, no egg, no dairy 

These ridiculously cute sandwich cookies, featuring a dairy free chocolate ganache and sweet strawberry jam, are a guaranteed crowd-pleaser (and not just because they’re free of the 14 most common food allergens). 

Brown Butter Snickerdoodles
Cotter Crunch

19. Brown Butter Snickerdoodles

  • Time Commitment: 1 hour 
    Why I Love It: <500 calories, low carb, gluten-free 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no wheat, no egg 

The brown butter in this gluten-free batter yields such a rich, nutty flavor that you’ll never settle for a standard snickerdoodle again.

Pumpkin Pecan Polvorones Allergy Friendly Cookies
Cookie and Kate

20. Pumpkin Pecan Polvorones

  • Time Commitment: 40 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <500 calories, vegan, special occasion-worthy 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no egg, no dairy 

A seasonal twist on the classic Mexican wedding cookie—these polvorones are sure to please every PSL fan around.  And, no, you cannot have too much powdered sugar. 

Fluffy 1-Bowl Sugar Cookies
Minimalist Baker

21. Fluffy 1-Bowl Sugar Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 37 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, vegan, gluten-free, low carb, one bowl 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no egg, no dairy, no wheat 

Another one bowl baking recipe for folks who want the sweet reward without all the cleanup—these airy and light sugar cookies are proof that vegan and gluten-free cookies needn’t be dense, indigestible rocks. In fact, we’d argue that they are superior to the (sometimes cardboard-like) traditional sugar cookie…and they’re damn pretty, too. 

Banana Chocolate Chip Breakfast Cookies
Sally’s Baking Addiction

22. Banana Chocolate Chip Breakfast Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 45 minutes 
    Why I Love It: vegan, gluten-free, <10 ingredients 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no egg, no dairy, no wheat 

A slab of banana bread used to feel like a dreamy AM indulgence…but that was before you paired your morning coffee with this chocolatey gluten- and dairy-free upgrade. 

Chocolate Dipped Coconut Caramel Macaroons Allergy Friendly Cookies
Half Baked Harvest

23. Chocolate Dipped Coconut Caramel Macaroons

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes
  • Why I Love It: <10 ingredients, vegan, <500 calories, gluten-free 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no egg, no dairy, no wheat 

Impress guests and win new friends with these tasty and incredibly beautiful chocolate-dipped macaroons. Just be warned—the oohs and aahs are liable to make you blush.

Vegan Red Velvet Cookies
Make It Dairy Free

24. Vegan Red Velvet Cookies

  • Time Commitment: 30 minutes 
    Why I Love It: <30 minutes, <500 calories, vegan 
  • Allergen Info: no peanuts, no tree nuts, no egg, no dairy 

Here, a vegan cookie twist on a beloved cake that boasts all the familiar flavors, plus a swoon-worthy texture combo with a crispy exterior and melty, soft center. 


Resized 20230822 160749 1707534340613

Freelance PureWow Editor

  • Has 5+ years of experience writing family, travel and wellness content for PureWow
  • Previously worked as a copy editor, proofreader and research assistant for two prominent authors
  • Studied Sociology, Political Science and Philosophy in the CUNY Baccalaureate independent study program.