ComScore

7 Things a Fashion Stylist Would Never Buy

Plus one shopping rule they always follow

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

things a stylist would never buy CAT
Christian Vierig/Getty Images

Have you ever wondered what a fashion expert might make of your wardrobe? Which pieces would they suggest you toss immediately and which would they praise you for having the impressive fashion sense to purchase in the first place? Of course, you could hire a personal wardrobe stylist to walk you through the specifics of your individual clothing collection, but I thought it might be a good idea to cut to the chase and find out generally what items a fashion stylist would never buy for themselves, or their clients. So I had a chat with three professional fashion stylists to learn what they would never buy, plus advice on what to opt for instead.

Want to know which buzzy products are really worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

Meet the Experts

  • Jamie Frankel is a professional stylist who’s worked with the likes of Harper’s Bazaar, Elle and Net-a-Porter.
  • Solange Franklin is a stylist and fashion consultant who has worked with numerous celebrity clients, including Serena Williams, Solange Knowles, Tracee Ellis Ross and Kerry Washington.
  • Samantha Dawn is a personal stylist and style coach who specializes in working with high level female leaders and entrepreneurs.

5 Rules for Wearing Wide-Leg Pleated Pants as a Petite, According to a 5’ 1” Editor and a Stylist


a woman carrying shopping bags from zara and mango
Krisztian Bocsi/Bloomberg via Getty Images

1. Lots of Fast Fashion

“Try to limit your consumption of fast fashion which is mostly made of synthetic materials which are extremely damaging to the environment,” says Frankel. Indeed, many inexpensive brands use a ton of chemicals and produce lots of harmful waste when constructing their cheap but trendy designs. It’s much better to invest in fewer, better-made pieces than to blow your fall shopping budget on a series of $25 dresses. You don’t even need to spend a ton in order to shop smarter. Brands like Madewell, American Eagle Outfitters and Outerknown all have sustainably made options, and Nordstrom now allows shoppers to limit their search to only sustainable brands. As for Frankel, she suggests checking out Mother of Pearl for more high-end eco-friendly designs.

two women carrying chanel handbags
Jeremy Moeller/Getty Images

2. Blatant Knockoffs

“If there's a knockoff version of a designer item, I encourage myself and clients to save up for the real deal or find the vintage version” says Franklin. “I have so many designer friends and it is truly heartbreaking to see their emotional and artistic labor swiped and sold at a fraction of the cost in fast fashion stores.” Truth be told, I have been guilty of this in the past, but ultimately it just didn’t feel that satisfying purchasing a lower-quality item instead of the thing I actually wanted. You may also find in waiting that your need for the splurge piece was more of a fleeting fancy, saving you both money and closet space to spend on things you’ll love and use for longer than a few months.

a woman waering leopard jeans and carrying a bag decorated with bag charms
Jeremy Moeller/Getty Images

3. Every Hot New Trend

Not every trend works for every person—not because of your body type or age, but because not every trend fits in with your lifestyle or personal vibes. I’ve never really felt like I’m pulling off bike shorts, and my sister has long balked at the rise of Crocs. But according to my experts that is absolutely a-OK. “I wouldn’t recommend buying anything that doesn’t align with or express who you are,” advises Dawn. “Trends are fun, but they don’t create your personal style.” If leopard print or bag charms don’t appeal to you, simply move on. Instead, invest your money and closet space in foundational pieces that can be dressed up with accessories or the occasional trendy top.

things a fashion stylist would never buy white skinny jeans
Kirstin Sinclair/Getty Images

4. White Skinny Jeans

Dawn is personally not a fan of skinny jeans of any wash, noting they all too often “create an imbalance of my proportions and emphasize parts of my body I don’t want emphasized.” But for those who do like skinnies, Frankel still advises against buying white-wash skinny jeans.

“Don't get me wrong, I love a wide leg or slouchy white jean, especially an off white bone color, but as a skinny they just give me Real Housewives of New Jersey vibes,” says Frankel. And while I would never knock Teresa or Danielle and those with similar fashion sense for sporting skin-tight white denim, I agree that a looser silhouette is often much more flattering. (And less likely to require specific underwear.)

two women wearing matching coats in different colors
Edward Berthelot/Getty Images

5. The Same Thing in Every Color

Have you ever purchased a dress you loved so much you considered going back and stocking up on one in every color or print the brand has to offer? It may be tempting, but Frankel thinks you’re better off trying something new. “You’ll most likely wear the original color the most,” she notes, suggesting there’s a reason you selected that particular dress over the other options in the first place. “It may be acceptable with things like T-shirts and tanks, but otherwise stay creative with your purchases.”

a woman wearing gucci sunglasses
Edward Berthelot/Getty Images

6. Expensive Sunglasses

“Sunglasses are a great example of an item that I just won’t spend a ton of money on because I know they’re a pretty low-cost item to make, regardless of the brand, and I’m prone to losing or breaking them,” admits Franklin. “And if not me, my husband or my daughter will get to them!” There are tons of fantastic middle-of-the-road sunglass brands out there that are high quality but cost half as much as designer labels—like Quay, Le Specs and Goodr—so why not shop around for something unique instead of following the labels?

a woman wearing uncomfortable heels
Edward Berthelot/Getty Images

7. Uncomfortable Shoes

This should probably go without saying, but if your feet hurt after wearing your new shoes for a quick spin around your living room, there’s basically zero chance you’ll ever really leave the house in them. Frankel knows it’s hard to say no to a pretty pair of pumps, “but just because you love them so much, never give in to the little voice inside that tells you, I'll break them in,” because realistically you won’t. There’s also a strong chance not even breaking them in would improve you comfort level. “If they are uncomfortable from the start, there’s no reason to buy them.”

a woman wearing a wool coat and loafers with yello socks
Streetstyleshooters/Getty Images

When in Doubt, Consider the Cost Per Wear

Both Dawn and Franklin mentioned using the idea of “cost per wear” to decide whether or not something is truly worth purchasing. As Dawn explains, “For every dollar I spend, that should be the amount of times I should wear something before it starts to break down on me.” In other words, if you can wear a pair of $100 shoes 100 times before you start to notice visible wear and tear, then you’ve effectively paid $1 for each time you wore them.

“I am a big advocate at looking at the materials before I buy something,” adds Dawn. “This gives me an estimate of life expectancy and helps me determine if the materials match the price point. Myself and my clients want to buy quality pieces, not just a brand name.” And Franklin wholeheartedly agrees. “Cost per wear is the longstanding fashion math I use to ensure there's logic in what can be an emotional boobytrap: shopping! In addition to the number on the tag, I think about the expense required to bring this item to life: working conditions, quality of fabric, the expected life cycle of the garment, and the mission of the brand. I recently partnered with Knix and a hero product of theirs, the SculptRib bodysuit, fits these calculations, plus it has endless styling versatility (layer under oversized or sharply tailored suiting, pair with jeans or high-waisted skirts).”




unnamed

Editor

  • Covers fashion, trends and all things running
  • Received certification as an RRCA run coach
  • Has worked in fashion for over a decade

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.