ComScore

I’ve Travelled 5,442 Miles with My Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer Coat (& Haven’t Looked Back Since)

From a skeptic to a devotee

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

  • Value: 20/20
  • Functionality: 18/20
  • Quality: 20/20
  • Longevity: 20/20
  • Warmth: 19/20

Total: 97/100

I must confess: I never understood the hype around the pricey Canada Goose coats…that is before, I got my hands on one. As a Southern California native, I didn’t really *need* a winter coat (I mean, the weather rarely drops below 40 degrees), so dropping a dime on a Canada Goose style that can range anywhere from $525 to $2,395 didn’t seem financially smart for my SoCal living situation. ICYDK, the brand is distinguished for having some of the best winter jackets on the market that can withstand below freezing temperatures—I’m talking an ‘Extreme’ level Thermal Experience Index (TEI) of -25 degrees Fahrenheit and below. Every coat is made with la crème de la crème fabrics and materials like down and Pima cotton and come with a lifetime warranty, really making that investment worthwhile.

Last year, the brand gave me the chance to test out the Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer ($1,650), and I jumped at the opportunity (after all, what better way to look at the buzzy brand than with apprehensive eyes), and now that I live in London, where we’ve already seen first snowfall, my puffer has never seen more use or travelled more miles. From LA to London, here’s my honest review of my Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer coat, including a breakdown of the quality, fit, functionality, value and warmth.

The PureWow100 is a scale our editors use to vet new products and services, so you know what’s worth the spend—and what’s total hype. Learn more about our process here.

My Review of the Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer

canada-goose-garnet-cropped-puffer-review sizing
Stephanie Meraz

How Is the Sizing?

First things first, when it comes to finding your ideal size in a Canada Goose coat, my rule of thumb is to always stick to your usual size. Many of the brand’s designs, like the Garnet puffer, are made with layering in mind, hence why buyers find the jackets so comfortable and not a bit stuffy. According to Canada Goose’s size chart, I’m a size small, but I ended up opting for a size medium because I wasn’t aware of their roomy nature, though I wouldn’t suggest following my lead. While the coat still fits me well, I do notice that it’s slightly roomy along the waist and neckline, so on those windy days in London when I’m trekking to my workout class in nothing but a sports bra and leggings, I can feel the air seep directly up the hem of the coat. Layering sweaters and shirts underneath negates my issue, but learn from my mistake and stick to your usual size.

canada-goose-garnet-cropped-puffer-review warmth factor
Stephanie Meraz

Does the Cropped Style Keep Me Warm?

With water-repellent and wind-resistant capabilities, this Pima cotton downproof coat had a lot of hype surrounding it, but after wearing it nearly every day in London for the past month and a half, I can wholeheartedly say it lives up to the chatter. Designed to withstand temperatures from 5 degrees Fahrenheit to 32 degrees Fahrenheit, this durable piece is made in Canada from 10 percent feathers and 90 percent responsibly sourced down that has a 750 fill power, making it extremely fluffy, light and insulating. The cuffs feature a recessed rib-knit finish to keep in the warmth around the wrists, and the exterior pockets are lined with the softest fuzzy fabric that have saved my knuckles time and time again from becoming chapped.

This is slightly embarrassing to admit, but after over a year of owning the coat, I’m just now discovering that the jacket has two interior drop-in pockets—a godsend for keeping small valuables safe and close to your person, especially while traveling—and an ingenious interior drawcord at the hem. Remember that woe I mentioned earlier about feeling the breeze come into the coat on my walks to the gym? Well, all this time I could have pulled on the drawstrings and tightened the hem to keep the gusts of wind out. (The more you know.) With that in mind, the warmth on this beauty goes up exponentially, especially for days when you don’t want to wear five-plus layers. I also love that it has removeable backpack straps—because I personally don’t love keeping them attached all the time—as well as a two-way zipper for ample ventilation.

All this to say, this is the warmest cropped puffer coat I’ve ever worn in my life. Best of all, I never want to take it off because it’s so comfy and soft.

The Bottom Line: Is the Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer Worth the Splurge?

What I Like

  • high storm collar design keeps wind out and neck warm
  • fleece-lined pockets, as well as hidden internal pockets
  • drawstring waistband is great for keeping wind out or making the coat fit more cropped

What I Don't Like

  • doesn’t come with a hood

Canada Goose

From the top-notch materials to the lifetime warranty, the Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer is one of the smartest investments you can make on a winter coat, especially if you live in an area that experiences cold temperatures like London or New York. If you’re somewhere where it’s constantly below freezing, you may want to consider a heftier investment like the Chilliwack Bomber Heritage jacket ($1,575) or the Alliston Parka ($1,275) for outerwear that’s more insulating and functional compared to this cropped silhouette.

Despite its minimal and stylish silhouette, the brand incorporated thoughtful and functional designs, like that drawstring cord and pockets galore, to keep you feeling your warmest no matter the activity or conditions. As for its longevity, I’m proof that the coat can hold up like a champ after a year and hold onto zero smell even after wearing it drenched in sweat post-F45 workout. While you can find warm pieces from other brands like Canada Goose, I promise you none will ever match up to this specific quality, warmth, functionality, durability and classic style of the Canada Goose Garnet Cropped Puffer.

It's safe to say, I’m a skeptic no longer.


IMG 0045 e1692204525583

Associate Fashion Commerce Editor

  • Covers all things fashion and shopping
  • Boasts over 23 years of experience as an avid shopper, having secured a personal stylist at Limited Too at the age of four
  • Studied English literature, communications and creative writing at the University of San Diego, and completed the Columbia Publishing Course at Columbia University in New York

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.