ComScore

Reddit’s ‘Severance’ Whipping Boy Theory Actually Makes So Much Sense

The Innie Purpose You Didn’t Even Know to Fear

severance-whipping-boy-theory: A photo of an antique plate with a design featuring a young boy and two older people holding the boys arms. On top of the plate is a hard-boiled egg cut evenly into six pieces.
AppleTV+

A few days ago, I wrote about the symbolism of the plate off which Helena eats an egg at the beginning of Season 2, Episode 9. At the time, I speculated that it might be a nod towards the theme of child labor and parental severance that the show keeps pushing us towards.

But since then, a new theory has emerged on Reddit that’s so smart, I couldn’t not amend my original one. Per eagle-eyed fans, the young boy being restrained in the painting on the plate is actually a “whipping boy” or, “a boy educated alongside a prince (or boy monarch) in early modern Europe, who supposedly received corporal punishment for the prince's transgressions in his presence,” per Wikipedia. In other words: The original innie.

Says Redditor Living-Jeweler-5600, “slicing the egg into parts represents the way they can sever someone into multiple ‘innies’…so that each one of them can be the ‘whipping boy’ for the outie. And another commentor notes, “Kinda on the nose for Helly and Helena's dynamic.”

severance whipping boy theory Woman at Bar
AppleTV+

Clearly, this “whipping boy” theory is applicable to all innies—from the laboring mothers at the birthing cabin to the toiling workers at MDR. They take the abuse so their outies don’t have to.

“Whipping boy” is also another way of saying “Scapegoat,” which, as any good Severance fan will tell you, is probably not a coincidence.

In other words, as we move towards the true meaning of Cold Harbor (which seems likely to be a form of death for an innie), it’s interesting to think about it in the context of scapegoatism. Does the innie die so the outie can live forever?


jillian quint editor in chief purewow

Editor-in-Chief

  • Oversees editorial content and strategy
  • Covers parenting, home and pop culture
  • Studied English literature at Vassar College

entertainment
/ Danielle Long
15 Shows and Movies to Watch This Weekend, Recommended by Our Editors
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
Gritty New Thriller Hits #6 on Netflix and the Trailer Alone Has My Adrenaline Pumping
entertainment
/ Dara Katz
I Can't Believe "Survivor" Is Letting a Contestant Wear These Shoes
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
All the Met Gala Themes Over the Years, From Dance to Manus x Machina
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
The Latest 'Dancing with the Stars' Cast Reveal Includes a Surprising Royal Twist
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
What Happens at the Met Gala? Here’s a Full Breakdown
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
ABC Just Revealed the New Golden Bachelor & the Choice Is a Giant Curveball
entertainment
/ Jael Rucker
This Murder Mystery Is Still on the Netflix Top 10 List After More Than a Month—and It's So Good
entertainment
/ Joel Calfee
How to Watch the Met Gala Red Carpet (Plus More Details About Fashion’s Biggest Event)
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
These 4 Intense Thrillers Just Got Bumped Down Netflix's Top 10 List by a Very Surprising New Show at #1
entertainment
/ Jael Rucker
Bad News, Morgan Freeman Fans—His Intense Spy Thriller Is Leaving Netflix in Just 3 Weeks
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Hold Up, 'Last of Us' Stars Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey Were Both in 'Game of Thrones'?!
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
This Intense True-Crime Show Is Now #8 on Netflix & the Trailer Genuinely Made My Jaw Drop
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
Pedro Pascal Has Feelings About *That* ‘Last of Us’ Death—and Honestly, Same
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Meet Peyton List's Boyfriend & 'Cobra Kai' Co-Star, Jacob Bertrand
entertainment
/ Courtney Mason
This Steamy New Josh Duhamel Show Just Hit #1 on Netflix—and the Trailer Alone Is Making Me Sweat
See More