ComScore

Did Dottie from 'A League of Their Own' Drop the Ball on Purpose? 2 PureWow Editors Debate

*Warning: Spoilers ahead*

Reboots are nothing new. But reboots that are well-executed and worth every second of your time? Now that's a trend we can get behind.

One standout example is none other than Prime Video's remake the of hit 1992 film A League of Their Own, which follows a group of women in the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League during the World War II-era. And PureWow's resident TV experts, Rachel Gulmi and Phil Mutz, are weighing in on the popular new series on their podcast, Stream On.

dottie
Parkway Productions

Aside from discussing the show's many strengths and similarities to the film, the co-hosts brought up a very important question that's sure to get fans thinking: Did Dottie actually drop the ball on purpose in the movie?

"I want to know where you stand on...what should we term this? ...Dropping the Ballgate," Mutz said in the latest Stream On episode. "The whole movie, the crux of it is about these sisters, and at the end, they physically collide at home plate and Geena Davis drops the ball. Did Geena Davis drop the ball on purpose or not?"

Gulmi's opinion? It's definitely possible. She explained, "When I was watching it, I was thinking to myself the whole time, like when she goes to the pitcher's mound to say do the high ones, I'm like, 'Does she do this because she knows that she's gonna hit it, and then they're gonna win the game? Was she trying to let her win?'"

Mutz also made an interesting observation that totally changed how he saw the ending. And his conclusion? Dottie intentionally dropped the ball to give her sister the spotlight.

He said, "At the very beginning of the movie...Old Dottie pulls her grandson who's playing basketball aside, and she says, quote, 'Now remember, no matter what your brother does, he's littler than you are. So, give him a chance to shoot.' And I was like, 'Oh, so she did this. She dropped that ball on purpose.' Right? Like, she's setting this up. Like, give him a chance to shoot. She's giving Kit a chance to shine at the end."

Gulmi agreed, adding, "When the little girls are asking for Kit's signature and everything, you see Geena Davis, as Dottie, just like smiling and she's like, 'Oh, I did that.' So, I'm sure I'm sure she did it."

Mutz said said that a case could also be made for Dottie dropping the ball accidentally. He explained, "In defense of whoever disagrees, [the way] the shot is filmed, it looks very much like an accident. It does not look like she's dropping it on purpose...I'm not sure. I think they want us to believe that it was on purpose. And that was a choice." Fair point.

To hear even more entertaining discussions about the best movies and TV shows, make sure to subscribe, rate and review the podcast.

Want all the latest entertainment news sent right to your inbox? Click here.

‘A League of Their Own’ Series Review the Prime Video Remake Expertly Highlights Stories the Film Left Out



nakeisha campbell bio

Associate Editor, News and Entertainment

  • Writes celebrity news, TV/movie reviews and SEO-focused entertainment articles
  • Interviews celebrities and covers red carpet events
  • Has 8+ years of experience covering entertainment topics

entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Netflix Renews ‘With Love, Meghan’ Just 3 Days After Series Premiere
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
If You Binged This Netflix Top 10 Show, We’ve Got Good News—Season 2 Is Official
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
15 Shows and Movies to Watch This Weekend, Recommended by Our Editors
entertainment
/ Alexandra Hough
The 40 Best Easter Movies to Get You in the Holiday Spirit
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
What Is Adam Brody's Net Worth? Here's How He Made His Fortune
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
The Top 10 Netflix Shows Right Now (Including a New Kate Hudson Series at #2)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Kate Hudson Stars as a Badass Basketball Boss in Netflix’s New #1 Show
entertainment
/ Marissa Wu
This Famous Julia Roberts Movie Has a Shockingly Low Rotten Tomatoes Score—Here’s Why the Critics Are Totally Wrong
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
This Denzel Washington Thriller Only Has a 38 Percent Rotten Tomato Score, But I Think The Critics Got It Totally Wrong
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Netflix New Releases: The Best Shows & Movies to Watch in March
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Oscar Nominee Mikey Madison’s Net Worth Is Major (Thanks to ‘Anora’)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Mindy Kaling Shares New ‘Legally Blonde 3’ Update: ‘It’s Like Writing Fan-Fic’
entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
‘Severance’ Season 2 Episode 7: Did We Just Confirm Reddit’s Biggest Gemma Theory?
entertainment
/ Philip Mutz
'Anora' Has Been the Underdog of the Year, But Should It Win the Oscar? Here, My Honest Review
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Everything You Need to Know About Demi Moore
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
Netflix’s New #1 Movie Has Critics Divided—but Fans Are Obsessed
See More