ComScore

Kelly Clarkson Speaks Out About Possibly Joining 'American Idol' as a Judge

"I can't do that"

kelly clarkson american idol
Getty Images

Kelly Clarkson will go down in history as the powerhouse singer and multi-hyphenate who became the nation's first-ever "American Idol," but that doesn't mean she's ready to move on to the judging panel.

When Katy Perry announced her exit from American Idol in February, Clarkson's name was among the first to come up as a potential replacement. However, while attending the 2024 Daytime Emmy Awards last week, the 42-year-old singer and TV personality confirmed that she will not take Perry’s place as a judge because she wants to focus on her family. She told ET, "No. No. I can't do that, only because I promised my kids. I was like, 'I wanna be there as much as I possibly can.'"

Clarkson continued, "I wanted a life for us. And we enjoy the park every day and we enjoy each other. As a parent—people get this—you only get so much time until they don't want to hang out with you. That's the reason [I can't do Idol]. It's my kiddos."

The singer also mentioned that she had to leave The Voice for similar reasons, adding, "It would put me in L.A., and that's why I had to quit The Voice, which, I love that team. And I miss them so much."

In case you need a refresher, Clarkson previously served as a coach on The Voice from seasons 14 to 21, then returned for season 23. After her departure, she got candid about why she left and told ET, "I put on a smile a lot of those times because I was struggling a lot in my personal life. I've learned a lot about what I'm capable of handling, and also what you should not handle. That was me saying 'bye' to The Voice and having this big move." 

Although Clarkson won't be joining Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan behind the panel in season 23, the co-judges already have an idea of what they're looking for in a third judge.

american idol judges
Eric McCandless/ABC via Getty Images

Richie told USA Today, "You've got to bring your character. Be who you are. Katy's Katy. It's like singing a Whitney Houston song. Don't try to sing it like Whitney; interpret it… There's a lot of artists out there that can sing, but to join a very successful team, you've gotta be confident of your space. You know who you are and you'll last forever here. It's got to be somebody that identifies with the young culture."

So far, the judges have mentioned Meghan Trainor and Jelly Roll as potential replacements, but nothing has been confirmed yet. Until then, we'll keep our ears open for updates.

Want all the latest celebrity news sent right to your inbox? Subscribe here.



nakeisha campbell bio

Associate Editor, News and Entertainment

  • Writes celebrity news, TV/movie reviews and SEO-focused entertainment articles
  • Interviews celebrities and covers red carpet events
  • Has 8+ years of experience covering entertainment topics

news
/ Greta Heggeness
Princess Beatrice’s Stepson Looks So Grown up in Rare Photos
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Selena Gomez Steals the Show in Hot Pink Dress at Fiancé Benny Blanco’s Birthday Event
news
/ Danielle Long
Serena Williams & Daughter Olympia Share the Cutest Cooking Moment—And a Surprising Fact You May Not Have Known
news
/ Greta Heggeness
Royal Family Announces Prince William’s Next Trip (& It Doesn’t Include Kate Middleton)
news
/ Danielle Long
Queen Camilla Makes Appearance at Cheltenham—and I Can’t Stop Staring at This Bold Accessory
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
King Charles’s Body Language Yesterday Was Intense—and it Spoke Volumes
news
/ Danielle Long
Kate Middleton’s Subtle Move at Royal Event Sends a Powerful Message About Tradition
news
/ Greta Heggeness
Prince William Takes on Surprising New Role After Wife Kate’s Triumphant Return
news
/ Greta Heggeness
Royal Family Posts Surprising Video of King Charles Performing CPR
news
/ Greta Heggeness
There Was a Major Shift in Kate Middleton’s Body Language During Yesterday's Outing
news
/ Destinee Scott
The Ulta 21 Days of Beauty Sale Is Back—Shop the Best Deals of the Week
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Jennifer Garner Has the Best Reaction When She Realizes What’s Been Hiding in the Bottom of Her Backpack
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Selena Gomez Shares Romantic Birthday Tribute to Fiancé Benny Blanco on IG
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Amanda Seyfried Had the Worst Wardrobe Malfunction (& Glen Powell Came to Her Rescue)
news
/ Rachel Bowie
Kate Middleton & Prince William Look Relaxed and at Ease in Rare PDA on Commonwealth Day
news
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Meghan Markle Opens Up About Prince Harry's Cooking Skills on Her Netflix Show
See More