The Betsy Clogs from Universal Thread have a metal buckle strap and suede-like upper material that can be cleaned with a mild detergent, per the brand, so if you opt for a lighter shade, there's no stress over keeping them stain-free. Plus, the textured bottoms should provide some traction while you're out and about, so they really are both stylish and functional (the best of both worlds). No wonder they have a 4.6-star average rating from more than 1,300 reviewers.
Some shoppers do suggest sizing up, however. I personally went up a half-size for some wiggle room when I picked up this sherpa-lined version of the shoe ($35) and it was perfect.
Nevertheless, buyers of this classic style majorly rave over the fit that's comfy from the get-go. Take it from this reviewer who writes, "I’ve been wearing them every day since I got them a week ago and they didn’t even take any breaking in! I’ve gotten probably over a dozen compliments and everyone thinks they are real Birkenstocks!" Yeah, these Target lookalikes are good, so don't hesitate to snag a pair (or two) in time for cozy season.