Quince vs. Naadam: We Review Which Under $100 Cashmere Sweater Is Best

Name: Naadam Original Cashmere Sweater Review
Brand: Naadam
Price: 98 USD

Affordable cashmere, for the win

By Abby Hepworth

•

Published Feb 6, 2024

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

Abby Hepworth for PureWow

Like most people, I am a sucker for all things cashmere. This is doubly true when it comes to cashmere that costs less than $100. Which is exactly why I couldn’t resist pitting Quince vs. Naadam cashmere sweaters against one another to see which affordable brand is truly worth investing in. After all, both the Quince Mongolian cashmere sweater ($50) and the Naadam Original cashmere sweater ($98) purport to be every bit as comfortable as knits that cost $150 or more, without sacrificing on sustainability either. But is one far better than the other? Read on for my honest review of both under-$100 options.

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

How We Tested the Quince and Naadam Cashmere Sweaters

I’ve owned both sweaters since fall 2022 (so about a year and a half) and have worn and washed them on multiple occasions to see how they hold up to frequent use. I also stowed them away for the summer and brought them back out again, testing their longevity from year to year. For this review, I rated the sweaters based on the following factors:

Value: Is the sweater worth the cost considering its quality and capabilities?
Fit: Does the sweater fit true to size? Are the arms and/or torso a good length? Does it fit well over the bust and hips?
Quality: Is the sweater made with high-quality materials? Is it soft and durable?
Aesthetics: Does the sweater have an attractive appearance?
Brand Transparency: How transparent is the brand about where the materials are sourced and how the sweater is made?

What Sets Quince and Naadam Apart?

Both brands are known for producing high-quality clothing at lower price points than their competitors (like J.Crew, Naked Cashmere, Everlane and State Cashmere), thanks to a direct-to-consumer model. Both brands are also transparent about how they’re able to keep their prices so low, with easily accessible information on how and where the fibers are sourced, where the clothing is constructed and what steps they take to offset their carbon footprint.

That said, Naadam’s focus is almost entirely on knitwear—mostly cashmere, but also some wool and cotton—for both women and men, whereas Quince’s product range is much more diverse. It sells not just cashmere sweaters, but also clothing in a wide range of materials for women, men and kids, as well as home goods and luggage.

Abby Hepworth

Quince Mongolian Cashmere Sweater Review

What We Like

available in 15-plus color options
free returns/exchanges for 365 days
holds up shockingly well from year to year
fits true to size

What We Don’t Like

plus sizes available in fewer colors
plus sizes cost $10 more
hand wash only

Quince

Value: 20/20
Fit: 19/20
Quality: 17/20
Aesthetics: 19/20
Brand Transparency: 15/20
TOTAL: 90/100

I’ll admit, I had very low expectations when ordering the Quince Mongolian cashmere sweater. I’d tested other budget-friendly cashmere knits in the past, but they were never as soft as the more expensive styles in my wardrobe. So, imagine my surprise when I discovered that Quince’s cashmere is just as dreamy and plush as sweaters three times the cost. Seriously, the material feels incredible and, even better, is ethically and sustainably sourced. Quince has a decent amount of information on its website explaining how it is able to keep costs low, especially for something like cashmere that’s traditionally more of a luxury.

As for the fit, Quince’s sweaters definitely run true to size. This crewneck silhouette is just loose enough, although if you like to layer thicker T-shirts or long-sleeve turtlenecks under your knits, you may want to go up a size. But while Quince does have a more inclusive size range than Naadam, it also charges more for sizes 1X through 3X (up an extra $10 for a total of $60). Plus sizes also come in far fewer color options.

To maintain that delicious softness, Quince recommends hand washing their sweaters in cold water using a gentle detergent, which for me means it gets washed less often. And while it has definitely held up well through multiple winters (and a handful of washes), I can tell it’s wearing down faster than my $150+ cashmere sweaters. It is still very soft, has minimal pilling and hasn’t worn thin in any spots, but it isn’t quite as lovely as the day it arrived. But for a $50 sweater to stay in nearly tip-top shape after two winters is an impressive feat, especially if I consider the cost per wear. (If you think in terms of girl math, my Quince sweater has basically paid for itself, and still has some life left.)

FAST FACTS

Size Range: XS to XL, also 1X to 3X
Material: 100 percent cashmere
Fit: classic long-sleeve crewneck
Care: hand wash using cold water or dry clean with gentle detergent; lay flat to dry

Buy it ($50)

Abby Hepworth

Naadam Original Cashmere Sweater Review

What We Like

available in 35-plus color options
can personalize with up to 4 letters for $20 more
machine washable

What We Don’t Like

not available in plus sizes
reportedly runs a little small
returns incur a $12.75 fee

Naadam

Value: 20/20
Fit: 17/20
Quality: 19/20
Aesthetics: 19/20
Brand Transparency: 17/20
TOTAL: 92/100

What was once the Naadam Essential $75 sweater has now become the Original Sweater after the brand increased the price to $98. Unfortunately, there doesn’t seem to be much explanation for the price increase, but I will say that despite the price hike, this sweater is still worth every penny. I’ve owned this sweater for almost two years and wear it regularly throughout fall and winter (and sometimes even spring), and it still looks and feels as nice as the day it arrived on my doorstep. The cashmere, which is ethically sourced from Mongolia, is shockingly luxe. I expected this to be a fairly thin sweater, given the price tag, but it feels really plush and the light hue (I own the camel color) isn’t at all see through.

The fit is also surprisingly flattering—not too baggy, not too tight—and has a good length in both the torso and arms. Naadam suggests ordering the Original Sweater one size larger than your usual for the best fit, and I have to agree. I got a large, when I typically wear a size medium, and while I do think the medium would have fit well, I prefer the looser silhouette of a large. It also makes it easier to layer things underneath.

Back to the Mongolian cashmere, since its launch, Naadam has been very transparent about where and how it sources its materials and offers up information on its website. On each product page, there is a note indicating where the materials originated from. Unlike Quince, Naadam’s cashmere is machine washable—although you should skip the dryer and lay your knit flat to dry. Of course, hand washing is best, but for those in a rush, as long as you use cold water and a gentle detergent, your sweater should come out of the washer looking good as new.

I will admit, I find myself reaching for my Naadam Essential cashmere knit more often than my Quince sweater, as it appears to have maintained that glorious softness a bit better over time and because I know it won’t necessitate a trip to the dry cleaners or an afternoon spent hand washing.

FAST FACTS

Size Range: XXS to XXL
Material: 100 percent cashmere
Fit: classic long-sleeve crewneck
Care: machine washable on gentle cycle or dry clean; lay flat to dry

Buy it ($98)

Quince vs. Naadam Cashmere Sweaters: What Are the Main Differences?

Despite their many similarities, these two knits have a few key differences:

The price of the Naadam sweater is nearly double that of the Quince sweater
The Naadam sweater is machine washable, although neither sweater should be run through the dryer
The Quince sweater is available in plus sizes with limited color options
Quince has a wider size range (XS to 3X), but also charges more for sizes 1X through 3X ($60)
In my testing, the Naadam sweater held up better over time

The Bottom Line

Both the Quince Mongolian cashmere sweater and the Naadam Original cashmere sweater are shockingly high-quality given their under-$100 price tags. And while the Naadam knit did edge out Quince for a higher overall score, if you have only $50 to spend, Quince’s cashmere is still a great investment for your money.

Abby Hepworth

Editor

Covers fashion, trends and all things running
Received certification as an RRCA run coach
Has worked in fashion for over a decade

read full bio

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.