ComScore

I Watched 3 Intense Thrillers on Netflix—2 Were Incredible But 1 Was...Oof

I have some thoughts

thrillers-on-netflix-review-mobile
Netflix

There is nothing quite like a good ole thriller movie that keeps you on the edge of your seat. Recently, I was able to check out three thrillers on Netflix that were quite interesting: Anna Kendrick’s 2023 directorial debut Woman of the Hour, The Guilty starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Idris Elba’s Luther: The Fallen Sun, which is a film continuation of Elba’s hit series Luther. Two of them were incredible, keeping me thoroughly entertained throughout with their tense, complicated storylines, and one of them…well, not so much.

Below is my honest review of each film.

1. Woman of the Hour (2023)

As obsessed as I am with the ‘70s, there was no way I wasn’t going to watch Woman of the Hour the night it premiered on Netflix. Serving as the directorial debut for Anna Kendrick (who also stars), the film is based on the chilling true story of a young aspiring actress who meets the match from hell on a dating game show when she is paired with a serial killer named Rodney Alcala (whose goal of going on the show in the first place is to target his next victim). What’s interesting about Woman of the Hour, is that the story is told from a woman’s perspective. There are a lot of twists and turns along the way, which is to be expected with a film centered around a serial killer, but Kendrick is able to strike a balance to create something that is entertaining, while still being sensitive to the delicate subject matter, as you are given the backstory of Alcala’s brutal crimes committed throughout the course of the 1970s. 

When it comes to period pieces, I also pay attention to whether the film nails the costuming, set design etc., as I believe it can throw a movie off completely if those details aren’t accurate. Woman of the Hour checks out in that department, as from a visual perspective, it indeed looks like a film that could have come from the ‘70s era. My only issue was with the diction/cadence of the actors:  People back in the ‘60s/’70s spoke/enunciated differently, and that difference is very clear when you have familiarity with that time period. Nonetheless, Woman of the Hour is still an interesting movie with a different approach compared to what a lot of filmmakers and studios are currently putting out.

I have long felt that we need less remakes, and more unknown stories being brought to the forefront, so again, kudos to Kendrick for bringing this story that many people (myself included) didn’t know about to life.

2. The Guilty (2021)

I had The Guilty sitting in my watchlist for longer than I care to admit, but I’m happy I finally had the opportunity to give it a watch because I am a huge fan of Antoine Fuqua—especially when he directs action/thriller films. Starring Jake Gyllenhaal as a troubled police officer who gets demoted to a 911 operator, The Guilty is quite wild, as it chronicles a distressed caller in danger. A remake of the 2018 Danish film Den Skyldige directed by Gustav Möller (I know…I’m contradicting what I just said about remakes), it takes a new angle on a real 20-minute 911 call listened to by Möller, which served as the inspiration for his version. The caller-in-question, a kidnapped woman named Emily (portrayed by Riley Keough), seems to have a new revelation every single time she calls the station. Emily has been kidnapped by her children’s father, Henry, who has a documented history of abuse.

The children, a six-year-old named Abby and her infant brother Oliver, are now left alone as a result of the kidnapping. Oh, and there is a truly terrible plot twist that you won’t see coming. The Guilty is a well-acted and well-directed film with a plot layered in a unique manner. Gyllenhaal delivers a strong performance as the lead, and I continue to believe Keough is an underrated actress with the potential to win an Oscar with the right role and opportunity. (When that happens, remember you read the prediction here first.)

3. Luther: The Fallen Sun (2023)

I’m sorry to have to do this to Idris Elba because I’ve been a huge fan going back to The Wire, but I just couldn’t get into Luther: The Fallen Sun, which is disappointing because I like the Luther series. I think my overall issue with The Fallen Sun is that it doesn’t live up to the brilliance of the series. You have the same components — Elba starring as the disgraced and highly-skilled John Luther, the non-stop action and the “by any means necessary” attitude Luther shares with the likes of Liam Neeson’s character in Taken. But something is lacking here. Part of this is that I find the series “restarting” with this film, so to speak, confusing. How can you expect the audience to disregard pretty much everything that happened within the series for a brand new plot? That only works if you are completely unfamiliar with the show and is actually a bit jarring. Are we just supposed to forget everything happened for the nearly ten years Luther was on the air?

If nobody else agrees with me, then at least Olly Richards of Empire does, writing in his review, “In 2019, the TV series Luther wrapped up reasonably neatly, with a suitably downbeat ending. Luther, a detective who’d been flouting the law for years, mostly with good intentions, was arrested, presumed on his way to jail. This movie never makes a compelling reason for restarting the story. While the scale is upped and there are some reasonable action sequences, it does little to advance the character and lacks the dark creativity of the show.”

Sorry guys, but this is a no from me. I think the better (and more creative) approach would have been to go with a brand new idea altogether.

Stay up-to-date on every entertainment story by subscribing to our mailing list here.



Screenshot 2024 03 04 at 4.32.14 PM

Associate Commerce Strategist

  • Covers all things commerce and entertainment
  • Has over a decade of editorial experience in both fashion and entertainment, and was previously with ONE37pm before joining the PureWow team in March 2024
  • Studied journalism and marketing at Columbus State University in Georgia

entertainment
/ Jillian Quint
The Newest ‘Severance’ Episode Has a Major Clue About What ‘Severance’ Actually Means
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Netflix Drops Wild New Trailer for ‘Black Mirror’ Season 7 (& Offers Glimpse at Star-Studded Cast)
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Crime Drama Fans Can’t Get Enough of Netflix’s New #1 Show
entertainment
/ Dara Katz
Everyone Thinks This Is the Best Part of 'The White Lotus'...I Disagree
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
Surprise! Jason Sudeikis *Is* Returning for ‘Ted Lasso’ Season 4 Despite Speculation About a Ted-Less Future
entertainment
/ Alexia Dellner
This Horror Comedy Is the New #1 Movie on Max (& It Stars Lisa Kudrow)
entertainment
/ PureWow Editors
15 Years of PureWow
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
This Psychological Thriller Is the New #1 Movie on Netflix (& It Stars Josh Hartnett)
entertainment
/ Danielle Long
15 Shows and Movies to Watch This Weekend, Recommended by Our Editors
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
16 Easter Movies on Netflix to Enjoy with the Family
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
The Top 10 Movies on Netflix to Watch Right This Second (Including 2 Must-See Family Flicks)
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
2 of My Absolute Favorite Throwback Movies Are on Netflix's Top 10 List Right Now
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
‘The Bachelor’ Failed Grant Ellis as a Lead—& Here’s Why
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
Everything You'd Ever Want to Know About Martha Stewart
entertainment
/ Greta Heggeness
The Top 10 Netflix Shows Right Now (Including a New Kate Hudson Series at #2)
entertainment
/ Nakeisha Campbell
I Binged 5 K-Dramas on Netflix, 4 Were Phenomenal & 1 Was Impossible to Get Through
See More