ComScore

I Finally Read Reese Witherspoon's First-Ever Book Club Pick from 2017...and I Have Thoughts

'ELEANOR OLIPHANT IS COMPLETELY FINE' ...AND IS A COMPLETE DELIGHT

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

reese witherspoon book club eleanor oliphant
Matt Winkelmeyer/getty images; Pamela Dorman Books

Fresh off the heels of reading Reese Witherspoon’s most recent book club selection—Ally Condie’s twisty thriller, The Unwedding, which I really enjoyed—it got me thinking: What other gems are hiding among the star’s book club picks? Naturally, I went back to the start and picked up the first-ever Reese Witherspoon Book Club book: Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine. And friends, I loved it. Read on for my full review (including why I highly recommend picking up a copy for yourself if you haven’t already).

The book begins with Eleanor Oliphant, almost 30 and living alone in Glasgow. She is, for lack of a better term, quirky. She follows a rigid routine that includes going to a nine-to-five bookkeeping job she’s had for almost a decade and making contact with as few human beings as possible. When she does have to interact with others, she’s awkward and oblivious to social cues and norms. (Her reaction to seeing people flirt is worth the price of admission alone.)

Over the course of the book, Gail Honeyman slowly rolls out details of Eleanor’s traumatic past, including stints in multiple foster homes, a substantial scar on her cheek and weekly phone conversations with her “Mummy,” who’s currently incarcerated.

Basically, she’s spent her entire life stuck in a rut, until she meets Raymond, a gentle, easygoing colleague who becomes her first real friend. At first she considers him slovenly and unkempt, but he’s pretty much the only person in the office—or in her life in general—who treats her like a normal person.

It’s funny, sad and satisfying to see Eleanor begin to creep out of her shell, and, without giving too much away, I will say that while her entrée to the modern world is bumpy and at times tragic, there’s a light at the end of the tunnel.

In short, this book is everything that Reese's Book Club has come to stand for: strong female characters, emerging writers and quirky-real stories that draw the reader in from the very first page.


stief author

Wellness Director

  • Oversees wellness content
  • PureWow's resident book reviewer
  • Has worked in lifestyle media for 11 years

books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
I Read the Highest-Rated Reese's Book Club Pick—Here's My Review
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
The 33 Best Sad Books to Read When You Need a Good Ugly Cry
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
The 15 Best Books of the Past 15 Years, According to PureWow's Books Editor
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
This Book About a Lesbian Party Clown in Florida Made Me Laugh…& Cry
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
8 Books I Can’t Wait to Read in March
books
/ Natalie LaBarbera
I've Logged More Than 15 Books This Year—Here's What's on My List for National Reading Month (Including a Reese's Book Club Pick)
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
4 Reese's Book Club Books That Will Make You Ugly Cry
books
/ Natalie LaBarbera
8 Swoon-Worthy Romance Books to Read This Valentine's Day, Including One Reese's Book Club Pick
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
I Noticed Something Interesting About Reese's Book Club's February Pick (Which I Can't Wait to Read, BTW)
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
7 Books I Can’t Wait to Read in February
books
/ Natalie LaBarbera
Katherine Heigl Gave Her Stamp to One of BookTok's Favorite Romantasy Series—and Inspired Me to Binge the First Book
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
ATTN Reese Witherspoon: This New Novel Would Make an *Excellent* Book Club Choice
books
/ Sarah Stiefvater
The Reese's Book Club Book You Should Read, Based on Your Zodiac Sign
books
/ Jillian Quint
I Read 4 Books About Horny Menopausal Women—Here’s What I Loved and Hated
books
/ Greta Heggeness
Reese Witherspoon’s January Book Club Pick Is a Must-Read for Fans of ‘Evelyn Hugo’
books
/ Dana Dickey
Am I a Jerk for Underestimating This Celeb's Bookclub?
See More