ComScore
home

Our Editor Was a Judge of the Inaugural ‘Best of MakerPlace Awards’—Here Are Her Top Picks

makerplace awards purewow mobile
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

ICYMI, around this time last year Michaels launched MakerPlace by Michaels, the only online marketplace offering handmade goods, classes, and how-tos from U.S.-based makers and artisans. This year, coinciding with its first anniversary, they unveiled a new annual program—The Best of MakerPlace Awards—and tapped our very own VP of Editorial Content, Candace Davison, to help select the winners.

Davison was the official judge of the inaugural awards, designed to celebrate the exceptional talents within the MakerPlace community and highlight the diverse range of skills and artistry that handmade makers bring to the platform. She was tasked with culling through a wide selection of handmade treasures to select just one standout small business in each of the 15 categories, ranging from “Best of Art” to “Most Sentimental / Tearjerker.”

The awards are not only a timely celebration for MakerPlace, but also for consumers with the holiday season fast approaching, after all. Many shoppers are looking to support small businesses and discover unique handmade gifts, with 92 percent of consumers purchasing gifts from small businesses during the holidays and nearly two-thirds (65 percent) saying it’s important to purchase items made in America.1

To encourage you to shop small this holiday season, all items sold on MakerPlace will be discounted 30 percent off as part of a special Small Business Saturday promotion from November 28 through December 3. Take a peek at the winners below, then visit www.makerplace.com to shop all the selections.

Meet the Expert

Candace Davison is the VP of Editorial Content at PureWow. She primarily covers home and food stories, but she’s also passionate about stress-testing the buzziest products on the internet, as she oversees the PureWow100 review series and our own awards programs. It’s her goal to separate the must-haves from the hype, so you don’t waste your money.

How the Winners Were Chosen

“Honestly, the talent across MakerPlace by Michaels blows me away,” says Candace. “There are such skilled artisans that it makes judging a competition like this a treat—and a challenge. I found myself carefully studying each product, the storefront and the seller’s biography, looking for the item that best fit the category while speaking to a larger cultural trend, filling a gap in the market, or offering a total surprise-and-delight moment. (You know, the kind where you didn’t realize you needed that mug, wall art or lamp in your life until you saw it—and it suddenly felt like it needed to be part of your life’s story?) And above all, I sought items you couldn’t easily find anywhere else: things that could be personalized or feel unique to the person who buys (or receives) them, things you’d cherish for years to come. Every winner here exudes a soulfulness that makes the product an instant keepsake,” she says.

makerplace awards purewow mobile home decor
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Honey and Ivy

Best of Home Décor

“How cool are these 3D-printed, midcentury modern-inspired lamps? Their sculptural design lets them double as art on an end table, casting a soft glow that adds warmth to the room (and flatters pretty much everyone). I love the cozy-yet-clean-lined vibe it creates, and how it nods to mushroom styles without trying to reproduce them,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile kitchen and dining
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Kolos Ceramics

Best of Kitchen & Dining

“Just when you thought you couldn’t find space for another mug in your pantry, Kolos Ceramics convinces you to clear a shelf. These small-batch ceramics are modern and whimsical, practically guaranteed to make you smile. The wide-mouth cup is just the right size for a latte—and for dunking. It’s such a fun way to add a surprise-and-delight moment to shake you out of the doldrums of your morning routine,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile jewelry
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Chic Mama Jewelry

Best of Jewelry

“These textured cuffs are delicate and stunning on their own, but the true magic is being able to customize it with a message from your kid, spouse or another loved one—in their exact handwriting. It’s the type of keepsake that can give you a jolt of courage before a major meeting or presentation, or imbue a major milestone (say, a wedding or anniversary) with that much more significance,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile art
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

HandmadebySaraKim

Best of Art

“Getting your whole family to smile for a photo—eyes open—is a feat. These beautiful paper portraits help overcome that challenge with ease, and they make for the kind of wall art you’ll cherish for decades to come. The minimalist design gives them a sense of timelessness, so the art itself won’t feel dated years from now, even as they capture a specific moment in time,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow crafting
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Electric Llama Designs

Best of Crafting & Fiber Arts

“Ryan Stanberry’s woodworking is outstanding,” says Candace. “The black walnut and maple squares on his 11-inch chessboard look seamless, and the chess pieces themselves have a great heft and modern shape that makes them great to display and play. I appreciate that he took the care to consider every detail—down to adjustable rubber feet and felt bottoms, so the pieces don’t scratch or slip about easily—so this isn’t just a showpiece. It’s something you can really put to use and enjoy.”

makerplace awards purewow mobile pets
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

AmberCraftStore

Best of Pets

“Tatjana’s crochet pets made me do a double-take. As someone who fumbles through crochet work myself, I was blown away by the craftsmanship of her Australian Shepherd dog (the speckled fur! The gleaming eyes! The softly curved ears!). The Mohair yarn adds such a realistic, cuddly touch—you just want to reach out and pet it. This would be such an incredible gift for a pet lover, especially anyone who’s recently lost a dog,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile accessories
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Childish Whim

Best of Accessories

“Guitar and camera strap bags have been making a major comeback, and this boho spin takes things to a whole new level of fun. The detailed stitches in the owl are incredible, and so is the ability to customize it—identifying your four main colors, so the bag feels uniquely yours in the end. Talk about a statement-maker,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile bath and beauty
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

NevaehBliss

Best of Bath & Beauty

“There is so much talent in this category, but NevaehBliss stood out for its brilliantly hued set of bath bombs. They’re like modern art for your bathtub, helping you create a spa-like experience at home. It was great to learn that not only are the bath bombs made in the U.S. using natural ingredients, but—despite their vibrant colors—they’ve been tested to ensure they won’t stain your tub,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile stationary
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

AkselRoseStudio

Best of Stationery & Supplies

“Could these gorgeously embossed cards single-handedly bring back the lost art of letter-writing? Maybe. The detailed feather pattern perfectly captures the organic modernism trend, with a satisfying texture to boot,” says Candace. “These cards have a quiet sophistication that’d make them great for sending any kind of heartfelt message, from a thank you to a get well soon, to a simple ‘Hey, just thinking of you.’”

makerplace awards purewow mobile fashion
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Autumn Olive Crochet

Best of Fashion

“Loose, cropped cardigans have been a major fall trend, and the loose crochet on this sweater make it the perfect piece to cozy up in—without ever feeling stifling. The mushroom cap designs popping up from the pockets give it a fresh, unique touch,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile wedding
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Wedding Band

Best of Wedding

“Tungsten is revered for its scratch resistance, heft and durability, making it a top choice for a wedding band that will last for ages. The hammered design is timeless, and I love that you can get a custom engraving on the inside to make this bespoke ring all the more personal,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile kids
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Alicorn

Best of Kids

“A personalized, wooden train is such a thoughtful gift for kids, but it’s even cooler when the recipient gets to have a hand in bringing it to life,” says Candace. “I love how this train doubles as a STEM project, allowing kids to follow the instructions to build their own locomotive. It feels so aligned with the MakerPlace ethos to give a personalized, handmade gift that inspires the next generation of makers.”

makerplace awards purewow mobile most unique
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

End Of Summer Candle Co

Most Unique Find

“Espresso has been everywhere this year—and now it deserves a spot on your bar cart, as one delightfully cheeky candle. Better yet, this stunner is made with eco-friendly dyes and vegan soy wax, and it features notes of coffee and caramel. It makes for a truly unique conversation starter,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile most likely to make you laugh
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Moxie and Mischief

Most Likely to Make You Laugh

“Show me someone who cannot relate to Moxie and Mischief’s ‘Sounds like tomorrow me’s problem’ print, and I’ll show you someone who’s lying to their present self. Moxie and Mischief artfully blends relatable quips with fun, vintage-inspired imagery to create collages that resonate. They’re a great way to liven up a hallway, powder room or gallery wall, sparking conversation as they remind you not to take life too seriously,” says Candace.

makerplace awards purewow mobile tearjerker
MakerPlace/McKenzie Cordell for PureWow

Pollyana Conte Art

Tear Jerker (Sentimental)

“After admiring Pollyana Conte’s minimalist watercolor paintings, I am convinced she could reveal the charm and character of even the most ramshackle house on the block,” says Candace. “Her watercolor ornaments would make for the loveliest housewarming or holiday gift for someone who’s just moved into their own place. Can you imagine having her create one, based on a photo of your parents’ long-gone childhood home? Or a grandparents’ house, where your fondest memories were made? I’m not crying. OK, maybe I am.”

1 Small Business Saturday Survey, MakerPlace, 2024


purewow author

Editorial Team

Our editorial team works with a variety of writers and experts across all fields to produce thoroughly researched stories that resonate with you. Our mission is to be that well-informed best friend who's always got your back, whether you need advice on dealing with toddler tantrums or the best no-chafe workout shorts to buy.