Maybe you’ve been tasked with planning your BFF’s next birthday party. Or maybe you made it through a particularly stressful week and still managed to be nice to everyone. (Go, you!) Whatever your reason, these nine NYC bakeries make finding the perfect cake a…piece of cake.
9 NYC Bakeries with the Perfect Cakes for Whatever Occasion
It’s someone’s birthday somewhere
•
Published Oct 25, 2016
Lady M/Facebook
For When You’re Feeling Fancy: Lady M
Try not to feel like a million bucks while eating a mille crêpes cake—a genius invention made up of 20 individual crepes layered with pastry cream.
Multiple locations in Manhattan; ladym.com
For Purists: Ladybird Bakery
The Brooklyn Blackout at this Park Slope institution is the chocolate cake we dream about (it has pudding in it, people).
1112 Eighth Ave. (between 11th and 12th sts.), Brooklyn; 718-499-8108 or ladybirdny.com
Patisserie Tomoko/Facebook
For Maximum Instagrammability: Patisserie Tomoko
There’s something whimsical and almost fairy-tale-esque about this bakeshop’s Japanese-inspired pastries, which include green-tea macaron cake and yuzu mousse cake.
568 Union Ave. (between Richardson and Frost sts.), Brooklyn; 718-388-7121 or patisserietomoko.com
Milk Bar/Facebook
For A Crowd-pleaser: Milk Bar
You’ve probably seen (and eaten) Milk Bar’s funfetti birthday cake many times, but the shop’s other creations are not to be neglected, like the unlikely but insanely delicious combo of chocolate chips and passion fruit.
Multiple locations in Manhattan and Brooklyn; milkbarstore.com
Butter & Scotch/Facebook
For Something That Pairs Well With Champagne: Butter & Scotch
Celebrations are not a time for modesty, which is why you need this Hotline Bling cake: dark-chocolate cake, salted-caramel sauce and gold glitter. We’re pretty sure Drake would love it.
818 Franklin Ave. (at Union St.), Brooklyn; 347-350-8899 or butterandscotch.com
For That Nostalgia Factor: Billy’s Bakery
For all the bacon-maple doughnuts and lavender macarons out there, sometimes you just want something your 8-year-old self would approve of. Icebox cake is as simple as it gets: chocolate wafers, whipped cream and pure, unadulterated delight.
Multiple locations in Manhattan; billysbakerynyc.com
Amy’s Bread/Facebook
For Something Not Too Sweet: Amy’s Bread
No surprise that the baked-goods geniuses at Amy’s make a mean carrot cake. And it’s packed with vitamin A under the cream-cheese frosting, so you can feel good about that extra slice.
Multiple locations in Manhattan; amysbread.com
Morgenstern's
For A Grown-up Ice-cream Cake: Morgenstern’s
OK, the customizable treats here are pricier than the Carvel cakes of your childhood, but boy, are they gorgeous (and delicious, obviously).
2 Rivington St.; 212-209-7684 or morgensternsnyc.com
@marlowandsons/Instagram
For The Friend Who Doesn’t Really Like Cake: Marlow & Sons
You may not fully understand her (seriously, how?), but you can get her this legendary chocolate-caramel-sea-salt tart.
81 Broadway (at Berry St.), Brooklyn; 718-384-1441 or marlowandsons.com
More Stories You'll Love
The Best Fast Food Desserts You Can Order Right Now, Ranked by a Food Editor
Here’s What to Cook Every Night This Week (March 31 – April 6)
Millennials, Admit It: We're Responsible for the Nation's Most Egregious Food Trend
Taco Bell Just Added the Dirty Baja Blast to the *Official* Menu, & It's a Liquid Key Lime Pie
Philadelphians Have *Thoughts* About Joanna Gaines’s Take on the Philly Cheesesteak
PSA: You Can Win Free Cheesecake Factory Cheesecake for Year on April 1 (I’m Not Joking)
Every Panera Bread Sandwich, Ranked by a Carb-Loving Food Editor
12 Wendy’s Secret Menu Items Worth Trying, from the T. Rex Burger to Cinnabacon Bites
The 8 Best Trader Joe’s Frozen Foods, According to Our Editors
I Tasted Every Appetizer on Cheesecake Factory’s Happy Hour Menu—Here’s How They Rank
The Best Things Our Food Editors Ate This Month, from Pizza-cuterie to Black Sesame Babka
10 Disney World Secret Menu Items, Ranging from Loaded Galaxy Fries to Christmas Pudding
Ranch Cookies Exist—And They Are a Shock to Your Tastebuds
You’ll Never Guess Meghan Markle’s Nostalgic, Go-To Taco Bell Order
33 Easter Salad Recipes to Complete Your Holiday Menu
42 Easter Cupcakes That Are Easy to Make *and* Adorable
