ComScore

The Best Birkenstock Sandals for Women According to PureWow Editors

Let’s get comfortable

PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here.

best birkenstock sandals for womenUNI
Abby Hepworth for PureWow

I have loved Birkenstock sandals since way before they were ever considered cool, thanks entirely to my mom. As memory serves, classic Birkenstock Arizonas were essentially the only sandal she ever wore throughout my childhood, often accompanied by socks when in the house. “I remember wearing them back in the ‘70s when they first became ‘cool,’ although I don’t know how cool they actually were,” she told me recently. “Then after having kids, I returned to them because they’re just so comfortable and easy. I had terrible feet before having bunion surgery, but my Birkenstocks were always a perfect fit.” It wasn’t long before my sisters and I were wanting pairs of our own and when we got them it finally clicked why these were the only sandals mom would wear.

The Birkenstock company has actually been around for 250 years, although the version we know and love can be traced back to the 1964 release of the Madrid sandal. It wasn’t until 1973 that the iconic Arizona sandal hit the market, scoring major points with the hippie scene who adored the comfortable construction and nature-inspired aesthetics. Cut to the 2010s and suddenly the “dorky” sandals were back en vogue, with sustainably-minded activists and fashion stylists alike, as well as numerous PureWow editors. I credit the incredibly comfortable-yet-supportive cork sole (that’s also podiatrist approved!) and the fact that they are built to last—my mom has worn her Arizona sandals for at least ten years at a time, and multiple editors also talked to me about how well their Birks have aged after time, conforming to their feet and getting softer and better with each wear.

So now we’re sharing our favorite picks with the masses. Read on for the best Birkenstock sandals for women, according to PureWow editors who’ve worn them for years.

Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds.

The Best Birkenstock Sandals at a Glance

1

Most Fashion-Forward

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle Sandals

read more

2

Best Minimalist Silhouette

Birkenstock Gizeh Sandals

read more

3

Most Classic

Birkenstock Arizona Suede Sandals

read more

4

Most Supportive

Birkenstock Mayari Birko-Flor Sandals

read more

5

Easiest to Clean

Birkenstock Arizona EVA Sandals

read more

Show More

How We Chose the Best Birkenstock Sandals

All of the Birkenstock shoes on this list come directly recommended by the PureWow editorial team. We chose only those styles our team has worn for at least a few months (or in some cases, a few years) to ensure our picks continue to hold up well over time, and supplemented the opinions of our editors with other customer reviews across multiple ecommerce sites.

How to Wear Birkenstocks for Maximum Style and Comfort


Most Fashion-Forward

1. Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle Sandals

Nordstrom

Audience Development Director Mary D’Alessio and I, PureWow’s Fashion Editor, are obsessed with these sleek, one-strap Birks. “I live up in the mountains in New England, things like heels and cute strappy flip flops aren’t what I would always call practical here,” explains D’Alessio. “The Madrids are a perfect sandal option to jazz up a summer outfit, but still feel like I’m wearing a good, durable shoe. They’re still comfortable and have great arch support, but the look of the slide makes me feel a little more city for a country girl.” I, too, find these sandals look more elevated than other Birkenstock styles, especially if you opt for the Big Buckle style. And they have the same amazing arch support with a cork sole and contoured footbed. As for fit, they seem to fit true to size for most reviewers, but do require a brief breaking-in period. “After the first few wears they’ve been fine,” says D’Alessio, “but if you’re like me and have sensitive skin I would recommend a little mole skin patch the first few wears while you break them in.”

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide andMedium/Narrow
  • Materials: available in oiled leather, nubuck leather, EVA, woven textile, Birkibuc and Birko-Flor

Best Minimalist Silhouette

2. Birkenstock Gizeh Sandals

Nordstrom

Ali Gazan, Executive Producer of Video and Podcasts, swears by the Gizeh style for a more minimalist, but still supper supportive, sandal silhouette. “These give way more support than your average flip-flop, but are still a fabulous shoe to throw on with shorts, jumpsuits and dresses,” she says. The combination of the wider toe strap, adjustable buckle and Birkenstock’s signature cork footbed works to provide your arches with the comfort they need, despite that streamlined cut. Gazan also recommends opting for a metallic, like the copper pictured here, to give your Birks a more elevated vibe. “I always opt for fun colors or metallics to make them feel even dressier,” she notes.

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide andMedium/Narrow
  • Materials: available in oiled leather, nubuck leather, EVA, woven textile, Birkibuc and Birko-Flor

Most Classic

3. Birkenstock Arizona Suede Sandals

Nordstrom

The Arizona may not be the actual first Birkenstock sandal, but it’s definitely the most iconic, especially in supple suede. Both straps are fully adjustable and they come in two different widths (like most Birkenstock styles) to ensure a perfect fit no matter what. And the material only gets softer and more comfortable the more you wear them. D’Alessio joined the ranks of Arizona fans years ago, but recently updated her OG suede sandals to a more fashion-forward nubuck leather Big Buckle pair ($160). “That big buckle makes such a difference in elevating the look of these crunchy sandals,” she notes. “I love pairing mine with a cute maxi dress for spring, but they also make me feel more put together when I throw them on to walk my dog. They’re so versatile and oh-so-comfy.”

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide andMedium/Narrow
  • Materials: available inoiled leather, suede, nubuck leather, vegan faux-leather, EVA, woven textile, Birkibuc and Birko-Flor

Most Supportive

4. Birkenstock Mayari Birko-Flor Sandals

Birkenstock

Birkenstock is well known for its attention to detail, specifically with regards to crafting supportive, comfortable soles that won’t break down after just one season. But the criss-cossing of straps on the Mayari style are also designed to provide extra support. The top strap, which hits roughly the same spot as the top strap on the Arizona style, helps keep your sandal in place while you step and prevents the constant smacking of your average flip-flop, which can put unnecessary stress on your arches. The combination of the two front straps requires less effort from your toes than the Madrid or Arizona models to keep the sandal in place. “I live in these sandals in spring and summer,” admits D’Alessio. “I love them so much I was out shopping once with my husband and picked them up to try on... when he quickly reminded me that I already had them in not one but two different colors, oops!”

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide andMedium/Narrow
  • Materials: available inoiled leather, nubuck leather, Birkibuc and Birko-Flor

Easiest to Clean

5. Birkenstock Arizona EVA Sandals

DSW

If you want something more lightweight than leather and cork, Commerce Editor Olivia Dubyak highly recommends the EVA version of Birkenstock Arizona sandals. “The EVA material is nice and squishy in the footbed, and doesn’t feel hard on my bunions like the classic Arizonas do,” she explains. “I wear these when I’m going for a cute, casual look and prefer the double straps because they’re way more secure than regular slides, in my opinion.” Indeed, there are a bunch of cute EVA options to shop, including the Gizeh, as well as a more traditional slide (the Barbados, $35) and a classic flip-flop (the Honolulu, $35) upgraded with all the support you’d expect from Birkenstock.

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide andMedium/Narrow
  • Materials: available inoiled leather, suede, nubuck leather, vegan faux-leather, EVA, woven textile, Birkibuc and Birko-Flor

Best Year-Round Style

6. Birkenstock Boston Soft Footbed Clogs

Birkenstock

OK, so the Boston isn’t exactly a sandal, but it is a total must-have according to multiple editors. Senior Food Editor Katherine Gillen and Vice President of Design and Branded Content Angela Pares both swear by these comfy clogs for any and all seasons. “I love them because they are so easy to slip on and off for quick walks, they're comfy and supportive, and they last FOREVER,” says Gillen. “Seriously, I’ve had my pair since 2006.” Pares also adores how versatile this style is, calling it out as a great alternative to everyday sneakers. “Aside from a sneaker, this is the most versatile shoe in my closet,” she says. “I got them last year after reading Megan Strachan wax poetic about them for months. She's a whole lot cooler than me and thus looks a lot cooler than me while wearing them. But I love that they are practical, yet currently in-fashion enough to wear with everything from leather pants and denim to sweats for school drop-off. I leave them by the door and slide them on to take out the garbage, but I've also worn them to dinner. Oh, and I’m obsessed with the insole.”

FAST FACTS

  • Size Range: US 4/4.5 to 12/12.5
  • Available Widths: Regular/Wide and Medium/Narrow
  • Materials: available in suede, oiled leather, nubuck leather, wool felt, EVA and shearling

unnamed

Editor

  • Covers fashion, trends and all things running
  • Received certification as an RRCA run coach
  • Has worked in fashion for over a decade

Why You Should Trust Us

PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women’s walking shoes that won’t hurt your feet, we’ve got you covered.