ComScore

I Just Rewatched 'The Princess Diaries' and Realized Who the *Actual* Villain of the Movie Is

It still makes my blood boil

the princess diaries a photo of cast
Walt Disney Pictures/IMDB

I hadn't seen The Princess Diaries in over ten years. Although I have the scenes and lines memorized at this point, it had been a while since I sat and watched the whole thing in full. So when I recently did just that, I was relieved that it still held up (despite my shifting views on the makeover scene—there is nothing wrong with Mia Thermopolis's frizzy curly locks!), but there was one thing I realized about the 2001 film: who the true villain is.

See, you can point to a ton of villains in the movie. Queen Clarisse for not being a more central character in Mia's life. Mia's mother for not telling her about her lineage. Her late father for withholding this big secret long before he died (though her finding the letter later in the movie is very much Mia's own fault). You can even consider the obvious 'villains' who wanted to see our princess fail: her bullies (Y2K Mandy is amazing though) and other royal families vying for the crown.

However, there is only one TRUE villain of this film and it's Miss Lilly Moscovitz. She was actually a terrible best friend and by far the worst character. At 7 years old, I never realized just how awful she was to Mia. Don't believe me? Here are three instances when she was the toxic friend you wish she left in high school.

Want all the latest entertainment news sent right to your inbox? Subscribe here.

1. Telling Mia to Get Over Her Dad's Death

This was the first moment in the movie where I wanted to throw my remote at the TV. It happened early on, after Mia already found out that she was the true heir of Genovia and was coming to grips with learning about this news from her estranged grandmother. While walking with Lilly, the topic of her father came up. Mia says, "At least your dad's still alive," to which Lilly responds, "Hey, I thought you got over that. It's been two months."

I'm sorry, what? Grief doesn't have an off switch. Whether you lost a person yesterday or 20 years ago, you may never get over their death. It's not something you can 'get over.' I was beyond shocked to hear that, especially coming from her best friend. Maybe Lilly should spend time reading our article, Things Not to Say to Someone Who's Grieving, huh?

2. Spewing Hateful Comments About Mia's Transformation

Fact: Lilly was a big time hater. If my BFF got a new haircut or was sporting makeup for the first time, I would be hyping her up. Mia's so-called bestie let her jealously show and was berating the princess of Genovia once she saw her transformation. Mia had the biggest smile on her face, but it went away the second Lilly says, "Oi. Who destroyed you? You look ridiculous, you should sue." Gut-wrenching.

If I was Mia, I would've told Joe to drive away and never look back. But instead she listened to Lilly tell her how awful, selfish and different she is. The 'quirky' character didn't even notice her friend was crying right next to her. I wish Joe's powerful words would've been a wake up call for Mia, but alas, she still kept Lilly around.

quotation mark

No one can ever make you feel inferior without your consent.

Joe (The Best Character)
the princess diaries villain royal title
Walt Disney Pictures

3. Taking Advantage Of Mia's Royal Title

Again, Lilly is a HUGE hater. First, she was upset that Mia was hiding something and practically forced Mia to reveal her royal title. Her attitude immediately changed after discovering the secret and then she had the nerve to try to use it to her advantage.

There was never a 'How are you feeling? What do you need from me?' Lilly only wanted to make her a guest on her talk show and exploit her secret. And when Mia misses the show, I understand why Lilly was upset. Her best friend made a promise and broke it. But she could've a) reminded her b) told her how she felt in a respectable way. I never understood how Mia didn't stand up for herself. Not only was she played by a boy she liked (who she later found was a total sleaze), but she was also trying to navigate this newfound fame and Lilly didn't once try to see it from her point of view.

the princess diaries villain
Walt Disney Pictures

Honestly, I can go on, but you get the gist—Lilly was toxic! I understand that they had been friends since childhood, but that doesn't excuse bad behavior. She never apologized to Mia, constantly gaslighted her and was never held accountable for her actions.

It makes me second guess the sequel and how I wish Mia would've left her behind once she got to Genovia. While I admit she was a bit tamer in The Princess Diaries 2, I can't help but wonder how it would've been if she wasn't in it at all. Even the actress who plays Lilly, Heather Matarazz, knows she wasn't the best.

Back in 2022, it was announced that a third movie was in the works and I'm beyond excited. I hope everyone returns (including this fan-favorite character), but I would be just fine if Miss Lilly couldn't make a pit stop in Genovia. Though if I want Mia's first love, Michael, to make a cameo, I might have to grit my teeth and bear an appearance by his awful sister. Here's hoping she learned how to be a better friend over the years. 



about face matte fluid eye paint review chelsea candelario

Beauty and Cultures Editor

  • Writes trend stories, product reviews and how-tos across beauty, cultures, fashion and entertainment
  • Over 5 years of experience as a Beauty Editor
  • Studied journalism with a minor in creative writing at SUNY New Paltz