ComScore

This Early 2000s Family Film Is Amazing—and I Can’t Believe It Only Has a 35% Score on Rotten Tomatoes

"It’s a fish-eat-fish world."

shark-tale-review: a still from the movie 'shark tale'
IMDB/Dreamworks

Rediscovering movies and shows you once loved as a kid can sometimes be a special, but confusing treat. On the one hand, those emotions that remind you of the good ol’ days come flooding back in full force and for a brief moment you remember why you loved that weird piece of media in the first place. But on the other? With this new era of the internet and those adolescent rose-colored glasses finally lifted, you start to see that everyone around you (and critics) didn’t love it as much as you did. 

I recently rewatched a film I wholeheartedly loved only to discover that it was rated 35 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, and I couldn’t help but find myself wanting to defend this beloved ‘00s flick. Granted, I was only five years old when it was released, but with this rewatch fresh in my mind, I’m demanding that it get a new score or at the very least be on others' radar. Trust me, this movie has all the makings of the best family night movie and I’m here to tell you why.

Let’s start with the cast that’s essentially filled with Hollywood royalty. I’m talking Will Smith, Angelina Jolie, Robert De Niro, Martin Scorsese—the list goes on. The movie also touches on themes of following your dreams, staying true to yourself and what happens when lies spiral (which prompts a killer wake-up call after dealing with the mafia). You’d think this is an HBO special that we somehow all missed, but it’s actually the PG-rated film Shark Tale. Throughout my rewatch, I found myself laughing way too hard at jokes that initially flew over my head as a youngin and repeating quotable lines I thought I'd forgotten. Although, who could forget the iconic shrimp monologue? If that’s not enough to convince you to hit play on Netflix, here’s a bit more on the film, so be sure to keep that remote handy.

The movie follows Oscar (Smith), a fish from the South Side of the coral reef with big dreams and a slightly concerning gambling addiction. After fumbling some bad debts, the ambitious fish finds himself in trouble with his boss, Sykes (Scorsese), who owes money to a dangerous mob of great whites. After “slaying” a son of the prominent shark family, Oscar finally moves his way up to the top of the reef and away from the whale-washing business, and of course, trouble follows shortly after.

On the other side of the reef, Lenny (Jack Black), is a vegetarian shark avoiding taking over the sketchy family business. De Niro’s character or the head shark in charge, Don Lino, dreams of his sons stepping up to the plate and finally running the sea but after the family of loan sharks (ha, get it) is troubled with grief following the loss of one of their own and the news of a resident “shark slayer” on the loose things take a turn for the worse with both Oscar and Lenny at the scene of the crime. The duo set out an elaborate con to fool the entire reef, but, you know, those things never work out. It may sound like a bit much for a children's film, but it's honestly more silly than scary.

shark tale review lenny and oscar
IMDB/Dreamworks

Despite the fish-y animations, revisiting this film was like stepping into a Y2K time capsule with enough recognizable pop culture references to make your head spin. From a brief recreation of the Hollywood Walk of Fame with starfish featuring names like "Jessica Shrimpson" to multiple mentions of Krispy Kelpy Kreme, this movie has sea-themed puns up the wazoo and I’m not complaining. To me, it’s one of the best parts of the film. I mean, there's a fish reporter named Katie Current played by journalist Katie Couric herself. And not to mention the hilarious pair of twin Jamaican jellyfish played by Doug E. Doug and Ziggy Marley. (Yes—that Marley.) Marley even has his own rendition of his father's famous tune “Three Little Birds” on the film’s soundtrack. Truly, this movie has it all.

shark-tale-review
IMDB/Dreamworks

But this isn’t to say this film isn’t without its quirks. The only part I wasn’t entirely sold on was the weird love triangle between Oscar, Angie (played by Reneé Zellwegger) and Lola (Jolie). Angie is Oscar’s best friend with a not-so-subtle crush who'd do anything for him (like giving away her grandmother's rare pink pearl so he can repay a debt) and Lola is an alluring, opportunistic fish who knows what she wants and will do anything to stay afloat. Both have a hand in Oscar’s decision-making in the film, but obviously, only one fishwoman comes out on top.

All this to say, this is a great feel-good film fit for the whole fam, even the adults. No 35 percent score will change how I feel about this movie (or any movie TBH) and it shouldn’t influence yours either. This film has the jokes, the best cast and an awesome rendition of “Car Wash” sung by Christina Aguilera and Missy Elliot during the end credits. For your next family movie night, put on Shark Tale and get ready for the laughs. You can thank me later.


image0 e1722622798857

Editorial Assistant

  • Writes across several verticals including fashion, beauty, news and entertainment
  • Over three years of experience in the fashion industry
  • Studied Fashion Media (with a minor in Visuals for Social Media) at LIM College