Reviewers Rave That These Liquid Eyeliners Are Best for Creating a Cat-Eye

There's a reason why “tattoo” is in the name. This felt-tip vegan formula withstands the sweatiest workouts or humid temps—yes, really. Simply add a little flick to each side and prepare to be amazed at how it doesn’t crack, slip or smear.

Is there anything worse than perfecting the shape of your cat-eye, but realizing the opacity is uneven? This convenient pot of formula leaves an enviously thick moisturizing line that is perfect for making a statement.

This Is Us marathon? You can count on this steadfast waterproof formula to live up to its name. Tough as nails, the pigment still glides on smoothly and evenly.

Not too thick, not too thin. Consider this the goldilocks of felt tips when it comes to creating wings of all shapes and sizes. Bonus: Formulated with lid-nourishing panthenol, this option will actually help moisturize your lashes from the root.

Featuring a fine calligraphy tip on one end and a brush on the other, this genius duo allows you to not only create a variety of shapes and sizes but gives you the chance to make small tweaks and changes without pulling out the makeup wipes.

Yes, reviewers promise that it is a serious smudge-proof and opaque pick, but most notably, this stick features a shadow tip to help complete an entire eye look with one product.

Smaller than most of the others on this list, this option from Lancôme can be used for tight-lining as well as wings. Plus, reviewers swear its smudge-able until it dries and then never budges.

Clinique boasts this as its mistake-proof pen. Tapered, the precision brush paints on a deep color from thin to thick, depending on your needs. Plus, it’s 24 hours of promised waterproof and budget-proof power.

Infused with castor oil and jet-black pigment, this felt-tip liner is gentle enough not to tug on the skin as you glide it across your lash line. Plus, reviewers rave about how well the waterproof properties work, like pool- and ocean-safe.