ComScore

I Have Oily Eyelids and This Is How I Keep My Makeup from Smudging

makeup tips for oily eyelids cat2

You know the saying “you learn something new every day”? I recently discovered that my eye shadow always creases and my mascara constantly smudges because I have oily eyelids. Through some heavy research (and much trial and error), I finally found a four-step process to keep my eye makeup intact so I no longer have to worry about touch-ups throughout the day.

1. The first thing you need is an eyelash primer. Not only will it condition your lashes, but it also helps to maximize your mascara and sets it in place until you wash your face. This one from Clinique goes on white, so you can easily see where you’ve applied it. I swipe it through my lashes and wait about 10 seconds before I put on my mascara.

2. Next, comes your mascara. My favorite is the Pat McGrath Labs FetishEyes Lengthening mascara. The formula doesn’t get clumpy and it has conditioning peptides that hydrate and strengthen your lashes. Depending on how messy things get during the application (mascara gets all over the place for me), I wet one side of a pointed Q-tip to clean up any smudges and flip it over to the dry side to make sure my lids are completely clean before I move onto the next steps. (Thanks, Kim K., for the tip!)

3. Once your eyelids are completely dry, it’s time for the most crucial step: eye shadow primer. I have tried a few formulas and the Too Faced Shadow Insurance Eye Shadow Primer takes the gold by far. The primer has the smooth consistency of a concealer and though it applies beige straight out of the tube, it dries clear. I like to apply a fair amount of it to my eyelids using a small brush. This ensures the product spreads evenly across your eyelids and covers all the little folds and creases. I leave it on for about 10 seconds to let it set; you’ll know it’s time when your eyelids feel a bit tacky. Rest assured, once your eyeshadow is on, it will dry to a soft matte finish. 

4. Last but not least, apply your favorite eye shadow. Currently, I have two favorites that I am constantly going back-and-forth between. During the day, I am obsessed with Charlotte Tilbury’s Instant Look of Love in A Palette. The “Number 2” sparkly eyeshadow is perfect for a daytime look—whether you’re going to work or have brunch plans. When I am going out on the town, I love Huda Beauty’s Naughty Nude palette, which is filled with golds, browns, pinks and purples to enhance any eye color. I would recommend using a tapered eye shadow brush to buff and blend a generous amount of shadow onto the lids.

Follow these four steps and, scouts honor, that no matter how oily your eyelids get, your makeup will stay intact for whatever life throws at you.

The Best Primer for Oily Skin, from a $7 Stick to Rihanna's Go-To Pick



Freelance PureWow Editor


beauty
/ Brianna Lapolla
I Get Asked If My Lashes Are Real Twice a Day Thanks to This GrandeLASH Serum (and It's Finally on Sale)
beauty
/ Marissa Wu
Gen Z and Gen X Editors Try TikTok’s Beloved Serum for Mature Skin
beauty
/ Chelsea Candelario
Need Mascara That Doesn't Flake? Here Are 17 Picks, Tested by Editors
beauty
/ Natalie LaBarbera
The New Summer Fridays Jet Lag Eye Patches Will Save Your Tired Eyes
beauty
/ Natalie LaBarbera
Merit Just Launched 2 New Lip Products Worth Puckering up For—Here Are 2 Editors' Reviews (with Pics)
beauty
/ Chelsea Candelario
The 16 Best-Smelling Body Lotions, Vetted by Editors and Experts
beauty
/ Chelsea Candelario
I Tried Rihanna’s $275 Signature Scent, and Now I Understand Why Everyone Says She Smells Like Heaven
beauty
/ Jael Rucker
Here Are the 9 Best Cream Blushes, Tested and Reviewed by Editors
beauty
/ Nakeisha Campbell
What Is 3C Hair? Here's a Complete Guide to the Coily Hair Type
beauty
/ Jenny Jin
7 Things Stylists Are Begging You to Stop Doing If You Have Thin Hair
beauty
/ Chelsea Candelario
A Beauty Editor's 15 Best Beauty Buys From the Past 15 Years
beauty
/ Marissa Wu
15 Beauty Tricks That Stand the Test of Time
beauty
/ Jenny Jin
Zendaya Proves 2023's Hottest Haircut is Back for 2025
beauty
/ Chelsea Candelario
Is the Viral Ouai Curl Cream Worth It? Two Editors Test It Out
beauty
/ Destinee Scott
The '90s Called, and It Wants *This* Deal on Clinique's Iconic Black Honey Lipstick
beauty
/ Delia Curtis
These 3 Bath & Body Works Retired Scents Are Back on Shelves
See More